The Good, The Bad, and The Fugazi


Fugazi- a slang term meaning, “false, bogus, or inauthentic.”

Finding the frauds, the overrated, the Fugazi is a key part of navigating March Madness. There’s a few different categories of frauds. There’s the fraudulent contenders, or the teams being labeled as “championship caliber,” that just aren’t. Then there’s some teams where the buzz around them pushes the ceiling a little higher than it realistically is. Lastly, a few programs have some eye popping records and not much buzz- they too need to be evaluated. And if you’re skeptical in my analysis, I’m including the BCR’s statistical analysis to identify those that are underrated and overrated at this point in the season.

  1. Fugazi
  2. Under-/Over- Rated Teams
    1. Methodology

Fugazi

I’m beating a dead horse here, I know. I’ve mentioned the shot distribution/tunnel vision offense and it hasn’t changed so neither has my opinion on the Vols. It reminds me of an early 2010s team in terms of scheme where too much reliance is on one or two players. In fact, only 2 national champions since 2010-2011 have had the point differential between scorers 1 and 3 greater than 8 points per game. It’s currently 9 points per game between Tennessee’s 1st and 3rd highest scorers. An injury or foul trouble could effect this team far more than others. Add that to getting swept by maybe the most inconsistent team in America with Kentucky, I can’t confidently say I love this team to make a sweet 16.

You’re 1000% going to hear someone talk about Louisville being the 4-5 seed that can make a run and win it all. I am not here to say it’s impossible but I’m skeptical because in order to cut down the nets you’re going to have to beat a Duke caliber team, or two. They lead Duke by double digits at half in the first meeting in the YUM Center before losing, then lost by 30 at Cameron Indoor. And to play further into this narrative, Louisville’s closing schedule is rather easy outside of trips to Chapel Hill and Clemson.

From an X’s and O’s standpoint, I don’t buy into one dimensional teams, which Louisville is the definition of. They’re currently 3rd in 3pt field goals as a percentage of total shots, with over 53% of their looks coming from behind the arc. And oddly enough they’re not a bad shooting team from inside the arc, they just don’t attack the basket. Sometimes its like they don’t believe in a bad shooting night. It’s turned into a problem: outside of the 2 losses to Duke, their other 4 losses consist of 4 of their 5 worst shooting games from 3pt range. Its a trend worth keeping an eye on, that if the 3s don’t fall, they won’t win. So ask yourself, can they hit their 3s in 6 straight games?

This one is ill timed. From beating your rival, losing the next game, and losing your star player in Caleb Wilson- a rough week is putting it nicely. I don’t want to rub too much salt in the wound for the Tarheel fans. Worries stem from the depth and the backcourt because I truly think UNC’s front court is probably top 2 or 3 in the country. Anything outside the painted area has been wildly inconsistent for the better part of a month. Going all the way back to their last non conference game vs Ohio State, UNC either shoots above 37% from 3 or below 30%. Seriously, UNC only shot between 31-36% from 3 in two of the last 13 games. That’s why we should marvel at the fact they buried 3 straight to take down Duke. Contrary to some of these other teams, UNC has the highest ceiling, but only with Wilson healthy.

I’m not saying this is the most fraudulent team in the nation, but rather one of the most fraudulent records in the nation. This team finds ways to let opponents keep games close. Since the turn of the year Villanova’s average margin of victory is 5.3 points. They’re 8-3 in those 11 games. It’s a good thing to be able to win close games, but not so good that every game is close. I’d maybe feel a little different if they could’ve closed out that Uconn game. I’m a big fan of Duke Brennan’s game and the team as a whole is a senior unit. When I’ve watched at Villanova, my biggest takeaway is that they don’t really excel at anything for a 19-5 team. They cash in less than 70% from the FT line, sub 200 in rebounding while sub 140 in FG%, so its not a more makes = less rebounds situation. And they aren’t a defensive identity team either. They just find ways to win. I liken it to some of the mid majors with lofty records- sometimes they aren’t really elite at anything, they just find ways to win in a bad conference.

This may come off as a shot from left field, but let me explain. Georgia was ranked early on in the season, around weeks 6-8. Since then they’ve been receiving votes in the AP Top 25 almost every week. And there is a lot to like about Georgia, but not enough for them to consistently be sniffing the top 25. They’re going to get in the tournament and I honestly don’t know if that’s right or wrong. The eye test is much better than the stats, but the more I’ve watched this team lately you can just tell they can’t compete against the big dogs of the conference for some reason. Part of it is just awful 3pt shooting or some really poor choice fouls in late games. Georgia has the athletes for sure and some great talent in Wilkinson, Cain, and Cyril. They strike me as the one or two power conference teams we see every season that is actually an underdog as the higher seed.

As the hottest take on this blog, it’s also low hanging fruit because of recent performances. My first gut reaction with team comes back to shooting and I know that was last year’s Achilles heel for this team. And I understand its better than last season, but when this team pulls up from 3 or just within the arc, I don’t get out of my seat. I expect it to miss and still often does because they’re less than 35% from 3. The culture, the intensity, the coach- everything tells me this is a stupid thing to go on the record for. I mean the team was worst from the field last season and made the elite 8. But my counter is that they were a deeper team, better at the free throw line, averaged less turnovers, and less on court distractions. If shooting didn’t matter in college basketball, Michigan State would be a top 5 team in my eyes. I feel dumb even saying this because I’ll be rooting for Izzo and the Spartans, but I have to let it be known this team might not match up to the 20-4 record.


Under-/Over- Rated Teams

Methodology

It’s always important to clarify what terms which teams are underrated or overrated. With the formula I built, it separates teams by two metrics: by BCR differential from “loss column cohorts,” and by BCR “loss performances.” In the first metric, I grouped teams with “x” losses, took the average BCR of those teams and then measured each team’s BCR differential from the loss grouping’s average. Example: Indiana has 8 losses, but has a BCR 12.2 points higher than the average BCR of the other 19 teams in college basketball with 8 losses. In grouping teams by number of losses, I dropped the 2 lowest BCRs from the average for loss groupings with 12+ teams. That way lower level teams in lesser conferences, who have 8 losses aren’t weighing down (and in turn propping up their loss cohorts) the loss groups’ average BCR.

The second metric, is “loss performance indicator (LPI),” which is a way of placing a team in another “loss grouping” based on what their BCR tells us. For Example again, Indiana. The Hoosiers’ BCR is more correctly aligned with teams playing with only 6 losses. Simply put, the BCR believes, “Indiana is playing like a 6 loss team, rather than an 8 loss team.”

Metric 1- BCR +/- Average

Underrated

1. Indiana (+12.2)

2. Arkansas (+11.9)

3. Ohio St (+11.4)

4. Florida (+11.1)

5. BYU (+10.6)

6. Louisville (+10.5)

7. Vanderbilt (+10.4)

8. Seton Hall (+10.1)

9. Texas Tech (+8.9)

10. Kansas (+8.2)

11. Virginia Tech (+7.9)

12. St. John’s (+7.4)

13. Alabama (+7.2)

14. Kentucky (+7.1)

15. NC State (+7.0)

16. Virginia (+6.4)

17. Iowa St (+6.4)

18. SMU (+4.3)

19. Texas A&M (+3.7)

20. Tennessee (+3.7)

Overrated

1. Liberty (-8.5)

2. McNeese St (-6.5)

3. High Point (-6.3)

4. Akron (-5.3)

5. Yale (-4.9)

6. Gonzaga (-4.5)

7. Belmont (-4.3)

8. Tulsa (-4.1)

9. Missouri (-3.7)

10. Santa Clara (-2.3)

11. VCU (-1.4)

12. Utah St (-1.0)

13. USC (-0.7)

14. New Mexico (0.0)

15. Clemson (0.5)

16. San Diego St (0.8)

17. Villanova (1.0)

18. UCF (1.5)

19. UCLA (2.4)

20. Saint Mary’s (2.6)

Metric 2- “Loss Performance Indicator”

*Number to right of team shows the difference between the team’s actual # of losses and where the BCR grades how they are playing. Ex: Alabama is 16-7, a (+5) means Alabama is playing like a 2 loss team (Actual losses: 7 – BCR LPI: +5= 2 losses).

Underrated

1. Alabama- +5

2. Kentucky- +5

3. NC State- +5

4. Illinois- +4

5. Arkansas- +4

6. BYU- +4

7. Florida- +4

8. Louisville- +4

9. Texas Tech- +4

10. Georgia- +4

Overrated

1. Stephen F Austin- (-7)

2. Liberty- (-5)

3. Yale- (-3)

4. UNC Wilm.- (-3)

5. High Point- (-3)

6. George Mason- (-3)

7. Belmont- (-3)

8. Utah St- (-3)

9. Virginia- (-2)

10. Iowa St- (-2)

Update: It’s important to use these two metrics as dependent on each other. Keep in mind the amount of losses a team has, such as Indiana. Because they have 8 losses, the average BCR of the other teams in their loss group is often lower compared to others. So while they are listed as underrated, they’re being compared to 19 other teams who have more losses and in turn proportionately lower BCR’s than other loss groupings.

Posted:

Updated:

Member of The FWAA

*If viewing on mobile device, click icon near URL along bottom of screen. Hit the smaller “A” icon until text fits screen