What is the BCR?
The BCR, or “Barry’s Contender Rating,” is a rating formula supported by multiple regression analysis. The BCR’s goal is to evaluate teams by putting less weight in wins & losses, and instead focusing on in-game statistics to determine a team’s quality, or “Contender Status.” Think of it like the CFP and NCAAM Tournament committees: they are tasked to pick the best teams, not most deserving.
The BCR’s Categories are:
- Contenders- The true favorites to win the championship
- Challengers- Teams that are the biggest threat to the contenders
- Competitors- Teams that you can’t take lightly: they will win some they shouldn’t and lose some they shouldn’t
- Contestants- Teams that don’t pose a real threat to the first two tiers
- Spectators- Teams that are struggling to compete with anyone
Another goal of the BCR is to identify teams with inflated records. If a team is 12-0 but their BCR is among teams in a lower range with a 9-3 record, the 12-0 team is likely worse than their record suggests. On the opposite end, if a 5-3 team is ranked near 7-1 or 8-0 teams, that team is likely better than their record suggests.
How is it calculated?
Each sport has its unique weighted formula. The formula grades offense and defense individually, and the overall BCR is a product of a team’s offensive + defensive grade + other non-offense/defense attributing variables. For instance, margin of victory is attributable to both sides, special teams in football is its own unit with some value, and road performances are highly valued in the BCR- which is another variable attributable to the entire team.
BCR’s game to game impact?
The BCR is a season long metric, not a recency based power ranking system. For a team’s BCR to rise/fall drastically, they’d need multiple good/poor performances. On a per game basis: in order to increase BCR, teams need to dominate, as big wins on the scoreboard & box scores are heavily rewarded, while teams that get dominated are heavily penalized.
Is there a SOS Variable and How important is it?
The BCR gives additional value based on “opponent difficulty,” or another word for strength of schedule (SOS). The SOS variable is derived by taking the average non-SOS-adjusted-BCR of a team’s opponents they’ve played so far, at a current time, and giving it a specified value by ranking it amongst all teams in the league. This eliminates “impressive” ranked wins vs teams who likely shouldn’t have been ranked in college sports. On the opposite end: if a team picks up a victory over an opponent who improves all season, the BCR SOS variable would increase proportionately.
This BCR SOS variable’s purpose is to add extra value to “split hairs” between similar teams, not prop up a bad team. A team won’t be ranked above another solely based on SOS. A great example of the BCR’s SOS variable weight is 2024 Indiana Football. The Hoosiers had one of the lowest BCR SOS in all CFB, but top 5 BCR.
Hypothetical: let’s say a team picks up a win over the #3 BCR team in game 5. But as the season progresses the #3 overall team continues getting worse and their BCR falls. The BCR SOS for the team who beat them may fall slightly as well.
CBB Example
UNC started as the preseason #1 team in 2022-23. They went on to miss the NCAA tournament. In the early parts of the season, they lost 4 straight. UNC’s BCR tanked weekly, and as the season went on, the overall SOS variable for those 4 winning teams took a hit as well because the “reward” in beating UNC was lessened.
CFB Example
In 2024, Tennessee traveled to Oklahoma for an AP ranked matchup in week 4. They picked up the ranked win, but Oklahoma got worse each week and the BCR reflected OU’s downfall. The SOS looks at all opponents played, so the Sooners’ fall in BCR effected Tennessee’s SOS variable through the season. One game/opponent won’t completely tank or skyrocket the SOS.
Other side: Texas Tech took out an Arizona state team in week 5 of 2024. The Red Raiders’ BCR SOS increased proportionally as ASU’s surge in BCR continued late in the season.
The SOS variable in NFL & NBA are set at a lesser weight than for CFB & CBB due to the size of each league and the differences in parity within each league.
Importance of Head to Head Wins
This section only applies to college football/basketball. Head to Head wins do matter, but the BCR takes a controversial approach that their impact is lessened. The BCR puts less emphasis in wins and losses, so that’s expected. But the main factor of the H2H impact is based on when the game was played. A team will rarely be ranked below a team they just beat, the week after the game. But the winning team 2 weeks after the game could be back below a team they already defeated. Sometimes the winning team loses the next week vs a bad opponent, or the defeated team then improves drastically over the course of the season.
BCR’s Successes
The BCR is an extremely good predictive metric for teams because it cuts out the noise of wins and losses. While only publicizing my work for a few years, the evidence is seen in previous rankings.
In 2024, the BCR’s CBB rankings had Florida, (the eventual national champions) at #10 on the same day the AP had the Gators ranked 18th (11/25/2024). By February, it accurately predicted 14 of the eventual Sweet 16 participants. In that same link above, the BCR identified three of the Final Four participants, making for 7/8 the last 2 seasons.
In the 2024 college football season, the BCR had 9/12 selected CFP teams in the top 12 from week 9 on. This included SMU, which was ranked 15th, 2 weeks before cracking the AP top 25. In 2025, starting in week 8, the BCR had at least 8 of the eventual CFP field in its top 12. This included the BCR’s top 5 from week 7 on, all making the CFP- a near lock. Indiana held a top 2 spot in week 6, all the way through the end of the season.
Purpose
I believe the best way to fully evaluate a team is by using a uniform statistical measurement and the “eye test.” The BCR could be a uniform measurement for evaluation, so there is at least baseline criteria to anchor arguments or “hot takes.”
Methodology
The BCR is supported by multiple regression analysis (MRA). This means the variables that are statistically proven to contribute to wins for a team are used in the BCR to evaluate teams. For instance, a team’s punting ability rarely correlates to wins- unless you’re Iowa football. So punting itself doesn’t have a weighted value in the BCR. But a team’s passing attack is highly correlated to wins, so it is utilized in the BCR at a determined weighted value in the formula. You might think “can’t I just replicate the BCR? What’s different about the formula?”
The BCR doesn’t follow the correlation(s) in the MR analysis “to a T.” The variables with less correlation to wins don’t have a larger weight than the variables with a higher correlation to wins, but that doesn’t mean they hold low value either. I took a little liberty in decreasing the value gap in correlation values between variables based on “game sense,” or basically things in the game we know mean more than what the MR analysis says.
A few examples: multiple regression analysis would tell us that rushing attacks in football aren’t highly correlated to wins. In a way it almost suggests that rushing offense isn’t important to generate wins at all. But looking at past champions in the NFL and College Football tells us this isn’t true. The average rank of the last 12 National Champions’ rushing attacks was 36th (out of 135 teams). The average rank of rushing offense between the last 12 Super Bowl winners- 14th.
In college basketball, MRA tells us a team’s 3pt % doesn’t necessarily contribute to wins as much as other variables. But since 2012, only 2 teams have made the Final Four shooting less than 33.1% from behind the arc. Efficient 3pt shooting is a near necessity for the elite level teams.
It took months of testing to determine the correct weights for what is a more realistic evaluation in measuring which teams are higher quality.
Check out the team rankings for each sport below:
BCR Player Evaluations
BCR’s CBB Player Ratings- A weighted formula that prioritizes rating players based on the player statistics that matter the most in college basketball. Some important variables are points, FG%, and rebounds. I tested the weights within the formula until I got an accurate list for each year from years 2009-2025.
BCR’s NBA Player Ratings- Similar to the CBB player metrics, but based on importance of NBA stats. There are less variables used than the CBB players metrics, and the largest weight in the formula is points.
BCR’s CFB QB Ratings- nine variables are used in this weighted formula, mostly focusing around passing yards, efficiency metrics, and QB Ratings.
Disclaimers
- Methodology page is intended to protect IP
- My evaluation metrics don’t reflect my personal opinions about a team.
- All data gathered from publicly available sources
