To no one’s surprise, the College Football Playoff is barreling towards another expansion. To me, it’s unwanted, unnecessary, and void of fan interest. There’s a valid argument it’s not in the best interest of the sport. The BCR typically evaluates 6-8 teams as true contenders, so 12 team’s isn’t a poor representation of college football’s parity, but the proposed 24 team format is. Of the 11 seasons of the CFP, the average margin of victory is 17.5 points among a sample of 67 games.
Decision makers only see the dollar signs, which are estimated $60million in ad revenue per CFP game. So, if you ever wondered what price is being put on fan enjoyment vs network greed, $50-60 million is the competing price. 24 teams is more than inevitable, it’s going to be rushed to our screens.
While this post on my site won’t make a large ripple in the vast ocean of college football media; fan perspective, enjoyment, happiness, etc. should still matter. What ever happened to “the customer is always right?” This is the BCR’s attempt to preserve the perfection that is college football.
Game by Game implications
While I’m not a huge supporter of the 24 team College Football Playoff, I’m not convinced the format effects the regular season all that much. Strictly as a fan, I believe it does because there’s room for complacency and taking the foot off the gas in different circumstances- something completely foreign in college football. Down 13 on the road with 5:30 left in week 10 as the #5 team? Maybe its confirmation bias if the #5 team did lose, it was because of this notion that the regular season doesn’t matter. Is that really all this is, a predetermined belief that will only turn up correct?
In opposition, I think about the grueling responsibilities of being a head coach in modern day college football. You can’t convince me that these guys aren’t trying to win as many games as possible, in every single situation. That’s the only payoff to being in that position. These guys aren’t spending their offseasons catering to recruits and families, charity events, and alumni hostings, and booster meetings, all while away from their own families, to only win 6 games. If they can win, they will. That goes without mentioning the psychopaths spread throughout college football. I’m talking about the guys who could win by 60 and wonder “why not 70?”
Season Calendar
Initially, I thought the 24 team playoff would be near impossible under the current “calendar” season of college football. Realistically, it’d be only 1 more game. Indiana played 16 games last season, that was with a bye in the CFP. A team with a bye would be playing 17 games in order to win it all, assuming they played in their conference championship. In order to play 18 games, the 9 seed or greater would have to run the table. 2025-26 Miami doesn’t help my argument, but I believe a 9 seed winning more than 2 games in the CFP under this format would rarely happen.
But for the sake of this conversation, the season calendar should remain pretty close to its current format with one major rule: do not play the national championship past MLK Jr. Day- EVER. Move the season up two weeks and cap the end of the season.
That is exactly what I’d expect the networks to push for. Playing a championship that late in January already competes with the NFL, who will always dominate ratings. Moving the season up to start mid August means you’re competing with what, the MLB’s playoff push, NFL preseason? It’s an absolute no brainer, the offseason gets 2 weeks shorter and the rest of the calendar stays exactly the same.
Auto Bids and Seeding
There is only one way to do 24 team seeding correctly and that’s with 4 auto bids, one for each power conference. The auto bids aren’t for the top 4 seeds either, they can be anywhere between 1 and 24. That leaves a lot of flexibility in choosing the best teams for the field.
No, I don’t think the G5 should get an auto bid. 2021 Cincinnati made the 4 team CFP, so under 12 or 24 teams it should truly be because you were an elite team, not just because you were good at a level below P4.
Forget the conference commissioners pushing for a set number of auto bids per conference. College football thrives on the “unusual suspects” succeeding and making headlines.
Schedule Changes
Differing from the “calendar” section, this focuses only on what the BCR would suggest to alter team schedules and their impact in the CFP race.
Conference Challenges
The first necessary change is mandating an 8 game conference schedule for all 4 power conferences. That means the Big Ten, Big 12, and SEC each drop a game under this format. With the 12 team CFP, I believe all power conferences should play a 9 game schedule, but 8 works better for 24 teams.
The resulting 4 non conference games gives some schedule flexibility to play other power teams. But of course no power 4 team will do this on their own, so a mandate has to be in place. Step 2 is taking a page out of college basketball’s playbook: the Power 4 plays in “conference challenges.” That’s right, “The Big Ten vs The Big 12 Challenge” or “ACC vs Big 12 Challenge” would solve the mystery of the “13th data point” in college football that the committee has struggled with for 12 years.
It’s all about selecting the best teams and it’s incredibly difficult to do. The transitive property, i.e. USF beats Florida, and Florida beats Texas, but Kentucky beat Florida. So where’s that put USF? Better than Texas, but worse than Kentucky? It’s an unstable way to evaluate a team. In order to select the best teams, you almost have to have similar opponents amongst shared non-conference opponents. With this idea, let’s say Arkansas plays Rutgers, you have just one part of the transitive property, but what if you can strengthen it by Auburn playing Nebraska? In the end we get 2 useful data points for true evaluation. For example: Arkansas beats Rutgers by 20 and Nebraska beats Auburn by 10. Both sets of teams will play each other and when Nebraska beats Rutgers and Auburn beats Arkansas, it’s a slightly more stable data point. Rutgers went 0-2, Auburn and Arkansas 1-1, and Nebraska 2-0.
It’s not a new concept, it happens every season, but not conference wide sample size. Not every team is playing another power 4 opponent from the same conference as their conference peers.
Honestly, I’d like to see a mandate of 2 games in the power 4 “challenges” each season, it adds more stability in terms of what non conference wins were flukes vs actuality. These networks love to build shows and segments around speculation in the offseason. We’re at a point where we televise schedule releases, lottery results that lead into talk shows of who will be selected where, and then 2 months later televise a draft that accomplishes the exact same thing. College football is no different, the Tuesday night CFP rankings generates real viewership.
Imagine a lottery show in May or June of the Big Ten vs SEC challenge. Ohio State draws at Alabama and home vs Missouri, Michigan draws home vs Florida and Arkansas while LSU draws at Nebraska and at Indiana. Do this conference wide and we strengthen the discourse around teams. If we’re worried about losses holding out teams, we’re definitely going to see some 8-4 team seeded at #22 anyway, why not have those 4 losses consist of other top 40 teams? The lottery system would also randomize the conference matchups so that each year would bring the possibility of a new conference challenge.
What about the Group of 5?
We can’t forget about the G5 teams. Many of the smaller G5 programs are operating largely based on the payouts from playing power conference programs. 2024 estimates point towards the average price of a “buy game” in college football between $1-1.5million per game. Initially it may seem like this format takes money away from the programs because of mandating their opponents to play 2 less games. But in actuality, the bargaining power of these G5 schools increases drastically because you’re changing these “buy games” from a want to a need.
Let’s assume the power programs are mandating 2 inter conference games, which results in only 2 open spots on power 4 schedules to play the G5. Basic economics tells us that as supply decreases (2 less games) and demand increases (power 4 teams need to play lesser teams to “guarantee” wins), the price to play these lower teams increases. It gives more power to the G5 to hold a bidding war for who wants to play them. In some cases, I think the G5 programs could make more in these 2 games than the 3-4 non conference games they usually play vs the Power 4 every season.
Another concern might be “these group of 5 teams need to play well vs power schools in order to push for a CFP birth.” That is not true. They’re already scrutinized for their schedules when they finish at 1 or 2 losses. In this case, the better records by playing lesser teams in lieu of power conferences + the increase to 24 teams. The top 2 or 3 G5 teams are almost destined to make it, not even requiring an auto bid.
The End Result
Let’s not lose the plot in what would be the real reason to push this idea: the great matchups. Ohio State hosting Alabama in a top 10 matchup week 4? Sign me up. The Big House singing Mr. Brightside in a rock fight vs LSU? What about Texas Tech hearing Enter Sandman as Blacksburg, Virginia sets off the seismograph? The Bounce House hosting Miami in a battle for the Sunshine State? This could all be before week 5. If this sport is going to be turned into a spectacle, rung out for every last dollar, at least make every week a main event caliber slate.
What’s Left?
If 24 teams is inevitable, the product across the board has to be more enticing somehow. There’s still a lot of questions on the best way to achieve this. Like what do we do with Notre Dame? They’re not being left out if they surpass 7 wins. But no conference means they don’t have to follow the “conference challenge” mandate. If it were my decision, they could never get higher than a 5 seed without conference allegiance. I don’t care if they played six top 10 opponents, there has to be a penalty somewhere because 8 out of 10 years, their schedule strength will be like 2025’s.
Admittedly, an answer I don’t have is how we preserve inter conference rivalries such as The Backyard Brawl, or Georgia/Georgia Tech, Miami/Florida, Florida/Florida State, South Carolina/Clemson, etc. The conference challenges idea might incentive programs to drop those games. Rivalries make college football special- they must remain intact. Do teams with an already established cross-conference-rivalry only have to add one more game with another P4 team? Do the rivalry teams still need to add 2 games and we just say “tough luck?” I don’t know.
Another one is how does the committee actively rank 24 teams? They do it every Tuesday starting in November, but it’s not exact at all. Think back to the Notre Dame vs Miami debate as weekly rankings released. What exactly did Miami do to jump Notre Dame the last week of the season? What about: why was a team like BYU penalized so hard? Clearly it had something to do with the Big 12, because it’s a team with 2 losses vs the same #4 ranked team. How do we change that to accurately rank the top 24 teams? Is another metric necessary, say the BCR?
Lastly, I can’t go without saying this: keep conference championship games. There’s no downside to keeping them. In fact, with 24 teams, we can finally start penalizing teams who disappoint and reward those who over achieve in those games.
Lots of other thoughts or questions pop up when talking about this 24 team format, and honestly, I’m not sure much of it has been thought through by those making the decisions. We just have to hope it’s a format the improves over time, not expands over time.
