Last season I developed an analytical approach to finding the best preseason Heisman pick. Fernando Mendoza made the short list. In August of 2025, he was 60 to 1 odds, meaning a $100 wager would’ve won $6,000. The question is: can the BCR do it again?
Summarized Methodology & Findings
When looking at previous Heisman winners to predict future winners, numerous factors come into play. Last offseason’s findings showed us that voters are more influenced by statistical performances than voters in the previous era, pre-2000s. Secondly, quarterbacks make up a majority of previous winners, and being in the SEC or Big Ten help tremendously.
Overall here’s the criteria we’re looking at:
- QBs: Pass for at least 4,179 yards, throw at least 40 TDs, complete >68.6% of passes, and throw less than 7 INT’s
- *If pass yards aren’t close, QB must be real rushing threat (>1k yards)
- RBs: Rush for at least 2,000 yards and 28 TDS
- WRs: record over 1,550 receiving yards and 19TDs
- Bonus criteria:
- Plays for Alabama, Oklahoma, or USC: (Each have 4 winners since 1995)
- 83.8% of Heisman winners have come from SEC or Big Ten
- Blanket Statement: Must be on a top 30 team. Ashton Jeanty proved it’s nearly impossible to win a Heisman at the G5 level, even as a top 20 team in the Super Conference Era.
Post 2025-26 Findings:


BCR’s Best Heisman Picks
Taking only the statistical approach would suggest that betting on any player outside the SEC or Big Ten, or that isn’t a QB, is a waste of a wager. Plus, where’s the fun in only following the statistical approach? It is better to use the stats as “guard rails” to narrow down the most suited finalists. In my opinion, the best evaluations are a mix of statistics + eye test. That’s why the list of players you see below will be similar but with major differences in “season outlook.” If a player was no where near the historical averages last season, what is changing this season for that jump to occur?
Secondly, this is my list based on previous season performance and other factors. I won’t be calling my shot that a true freshman or first year starter wins the award because its statistically unlikely and the BCR identifies suitable players based on previous season performances.
*List in no order
Julian Sayin- QB, Ohio State
Sayin is an obvious choice for a Heisman finalist this season considering he finished 4th in 2025. He met criteria for completion rate, INT’s, plus achieved 73% of historical era yards and 75% of TDs (30). With a target like Jeremiah Smith, he’ll be on pace to surpass his 2025 production. Losing Carnell Tate is an initial area of concern, but Ohio State has consistently been a WR factory the last decade+. Losing Brian Hartline at offensive coordinator may require a transition period too. One last factor that I believe could cause an increase in production is the loss of an all time great defense. Ohio State will still undoubtedly have a top 10 defense in the sport but if he produced at that rate last year, with that defense, maybe a few close games spur more stats on the sheet. It would be a massive shock if he wasn’t in New York come December.
Drew Mestemaker- QB, Oklahoma State
College Football’s 11th best offense according to the BCR was North Texas. Mestemaker was the engine behind it all and lead QBs in the “Heisman Standards,” totaling 92% of the 4,179 yard mark. He’s a true, old fashioned gunslinger- perfect for his move to the Big 12. The biggest obstacles in the road to New York, is the jump from the G5 to Power 4 and his INT’s, in which he had 9 in 14 games. The silver lining for the turnovers is that 6 of them came in 2 games vs quality opponents: USF and CFP participant Tulane. Statistically, there’s little reason to believe he won’t at least meet most of the criteria, but there is concern if the team will be good enough to generate enough buzz to carry him to the podium.
Darian Mensah- QB, Miami
The #1 rated QB in the BCR last season was at 9-5 Duke. Now at a seemingly rebuilt powerhouse in Miami, with 5 star talent, Darian Mensah is a big time Heisman contender. He’s going to have two 1000+ yard receivers in Malachi Toney and his transfer WR from Duke last season Cooper Barkate. He’s going to have at least four solid targets, not including TEs, and likely, a top offensive line. Mensah was 11th in all of college football in 2025 averaging nearly 36 pass attempts a game. Carson Beck averaged 29 per game. Was the drastic difference in attempts because Miami had a stud RB in Mark Fletcher Jr.? Was it because Duke had to pass to win games? Yes to both in my opinion. That’ll be the question for me this season: does Mensah’s production have a ceiling because he shares a backfield with a top 5 RB? Regardless, the stats and eye test really like Mensah heading into 2026.
Ahmad Hardy- RB, Missouri
Hardy was one of the most impactful transfers last season. He opened up 2025 with five straight 100+ yard games with at least one touchdown. 3/5 games he rushed for over 130. Then came the SEC and a few injuries. He finished the season as the #2 overall rusher, behind now WVU’s Cam Cook, and top 10 in rushing touchdowns. Jeremiyah Love finished 3rd in Heisman voting and Hardy rushed for nearly 200 yards more, but 2 less TDs in the regular season. Missouri’s first five games this season could put him in another spot to surpass 500 yards by week 6. Mississippi State got trampled last season, allowing him to run loose for 300 yards. Mizzou visits Starkville week 4. Unfortunately this offseason, Hardy was involved in a shooting. SEC Media days allowed Eliah Drinkiwitz to confirm Hardy was doing well, but could miss some of the early fall camp/season. His name still deserves Heisman consideration in the preseason.
CJ Carr- QB, Notre Dame
Let’s be real, people want a Notre Dame player to win the Heisman. They’re arguably the largest brand in all of college football. Jeremiyah Love was close, but they’ve got a better candidate this season. CJ Carr was a top QB in 2025, only 6 interceptions, 66% completion rate, but as far as Heisman criteria, not close in yards or touchdowns (66% & 60%). So where’s the jump come from? Losing the elite RB room of Love and Price will not be beneficial for the team, but absolutely will be for Carr. There’s no telling how many more pass attempts, yards, TDs Carr could rack up in 2026, with a less dominant run game. In 2025, he ranked 112th in pass attempts per game at 24. If the loss of a top RB room forced him to throw 4 more times a game, averaging 40 more yards a game, he’d throw for an extra 480 yards to easily surpass 3,000 on the season. Maybe 7 of those 48 more attempts are TDs too. That’d be 3200 yards, 31 TDs, and 6 INTS. It’s pure, but logical, speculation given he gets two great WRs back. November 7th vs Miami could decide the Heisman.
Trinidad Chambliss- QB, Ole Miss
Chambliss’ story is one of the best College Football has ever provided. From DII national champion, to Power 4 backup, to eventual starter, he found himself a few minutes away from a FBS national championship appearance. In just 10 regular season games reached 72% of the historical average yards, but only 45% of the TDs. Expect improvements in TDs, but maybe a smaller increase to yards as he loses four of his top pass catchers from last season. The lone returner, Duece Alexander, put up over 600 yards and they recruited the WR position in the portal well. Everything points to more games showing increase in production for Chambliss. Ole Miss has a massive opponent in each month of the season: Louisville week 1, at Texas week 8, Georgia week 10, and at Oklahoma week 11. Lots of chances for Heisman Moments.
Dante Moore- QB, Oregon
The second Moore announced his return to Oregon, the Ducks became a top 3 team heading into 2026. As a projected #5 pick in the 2025 NFL draft, it’s warranted. Moore met over 60% of “necessary” yards and TDs for a Heisman campaign last season and he arguably gets back more options in the receiver room. Evan Stewart and Dakorien Moore will be one of the best one-two punches in college football. Mix that with a stud transfer from UAB, Iverson Hooks. The real question in Moore’s Heisman hopes lies Drew Mehringer, the new offensive coordinator. He’s got a pretty good track record as a receivers coach, offensive assistant, and co-offensive coordinator. Oregon’s schedule gives the OC a few real games to mesh and test what works. There’s no doubt that a production jump is likely with healthy targets on the outside and an expected top end OL.
Jeremiah Smith- WR, Ohio State
Prior to this season, Smith was sharing the targets with two guys who went 19th and 4th overall in their NFL drafts in Emeka Egbuka and Carnell Tate. He still lead the team in yards during those two seasons. Now it’s just him. His numbers didn’t finish top 5 in the BCR Heisman standards but he surpassed 1000 yards in the regular season while his team dominated. The pass game wasn’t necessary in a lot of the Buckeye’s victories. In my opinion, the 2026 defense won’t be as all time dominant as 2025’s, thus closer games and maybe more balls are thrown his way. 11 combined TDs were hauled in by Tate and Max Klare who are now in the NFL. He’s been crowned as the best player in CFB for 2 seasons now and that kind of hype puts you in the Heisman mix from the jump. All I see for Smith in 2026 is more targets, more yards, and more TDs.
Arch Manning- QB, Texas
Finishing 11th in the BCR’s QB Heisman rankings is not a bad place to be. That’s where Arch Manning found himself after 2025. His biggest improvement needs to be completion rate as far as the stats are concerned. After 12 games, his season rate sat at 62%, including 5 games under 57%. That has to improve, not only to increase his chances at New York in December, but for the sake of the Longhorns. And he has more weapons than last season. Cam Coleman was the top transfer WR from Auburn and RB Hollywood Smothers from NC State will be in the backfield. Smothers caught over 3 passes a game last season for the Wolfpack and will add another weapon beside Coleman and Ryan Wingo. According to the preseason BCR, Texas has the most difficult schedule in the nation. A Manning, in November, leading a top 10 team, vs the toughest schedule in the nation? Yeah, I think he could be at the ceremony before the CFP.
Devon Dampier- QB, Utah
Dampier is the exact player that comes to mind when I say the QB has to be a real rushing threat. In 2024 at New Mexico, he rushed for over 1000 yards + 19 TDs. In Salt Lake City, he ran for 835 + 10 TDs in less than 11 games, in addition to 2,500 passing, 24 TD’s and 5 INTs. He opened the season as a Heisman long shot near +5000 odds, and by week 4 in a ranked matchup vs Texas Tech, hovered near +1700. If he plays well, and the Utes win the game, he’s likely top 5 in the Heisman standings. The game went the complete opposite. 2026’s schedule looks promising for another hot start for the Utes: Idaho, Arkansas, Utah State, at Iowa State, Kansas, and at Colorado. Admittedly, I don’t know the true impact of Whittingham’s departure, but with a guy like Dampier, I believe it’s easy to keep the ship on course. The production jump is a little larger in this situation compared to others. He’d need to surpass 3,000 yards passing, similar rushing stats, and a near exact TD:INT ratio. If Utah’s undefeated midway through October, watch out.
Honorable Mentions
The absolute hardest part of writing this preseason piece isn’t the pressure of getting it “right,” it’s leaving out so many incredible players. I often have to remind myself that the list of true Heisman contenders is pretty short. Only the elite get a real shot at it. And there’s nothing wrong with being just below that. There’s a ton of players I might like more than the 10 I put above, who are absolute gamers in their own right. But again, it’s for the truly elite with a perfect mix of stats, team success, a storyline, a brand, a name, etc.. Shoutout to those that just missed the cut-still unbelievable talents: Jaron-Keawe Sagapolutele, Malachi Toney, Kewan Lacy, Noah Fafita, Josh Hoover, Jayden Maiava, and a ton more.
Conclusion
There’s a ton of data out there about Heisman winners. Some of the trends can make the decision making easier in determining a preseason Heisman favorite, placing a futures bet, or the trends can just help you decide which Heisman band wagon you’ll hitch yourself to before week 0.
I could’ve made a paragraph for every single QB in the nation, and likely 3 paragraphs for the favorites according to the sportsbook. Some may ask why I didn’t choose to cover just the top 10 favorites. Mostly because I relied on my BCR metrics for players and QBs so if they weren’t a good statistical producer last season, they weren’t considered a favorite. Also, the preseason Heisman odds change constantly and are much more susceptible to whoever runs the best “campaign” in the offseason. It’s all smoke, no fire.
My Heisman Finalists:
1. CJ Carr | 2. Dante Moore | 3. Darian Mensah
BCR Predicted Finalists:
1. Darian Mensah | 2. Drew Mestemaker | 3. Trinidad Chambliss
