Preseason Heisman

For all that college football is, one thing makes it better than any other sport: The Heisman Trophy. Only 78 players have had the honor of boasting the title “Heisman Trophy Winner,” which is a less than a third of the people who’ve stepped foot on the International Space Station.

The new season is just weeks away and everyone’s looking for that Heisman future that will build their credibility. I for one have chased this feeling too many times. The failures launched me into a whole new line of thinking: a statistical approach to the Heisman. There’s a lot to breakdown, starting with some historical facts about previous winners, and at the end you’ll get the BCR’s best Heisman bets for next season-from a statistical approach. Don’t worry I threw in some 6500:1 picks for the sickos out there.

Trends in Heisman History

For the stats in this section, I focused only on Heismans won from 1995-present. One of the many things that interested me was if there was a statistical threshold these winners needed in order to receive voter attention?

Below is a chart of the two Heisman eras I looked at: 1995-2009 and 2010-Present. For each era, I listed the position of the players who won the award, followed by the “era averages,” or the average statistical output of said winners, at their position, in their era. The most important aspect of the chart is the last column: % of Winners below era average.

First, I only used pass yards for QBs. When looking at the two eras’ far right columns, it seems like the voting from 95-09 was based slightly less on statistical performances as 4 of the Heisman winning QBs in that era did not surpass the era average of 3,440 yards passing per season. This is where the issue of omitting rushing stats appears. I did some digging into the rushing stats for you.

Of the 4 QBs in the ’95-09 era that didn’t meet the passing yard averages, only 2 had significant rushing stats. 2001 Nebraska’s Eric Crouch had 1,115 rushing plus 18 TDs and Tim Tebow in 2007 rushed for 895 and 23 TDs. Matt Leinert actually had negative rush yards and Troy Smith only gained 204. On the flip side: 4 of the 5 QBs from 2010+ that didn’t pass for the era average, rushed for over 1100 yards and double digit TDs (Newton, Manziel, Jackson, Daniels). By adding in rushing yards, you could say the voting in the 95-09 era was a less stats based with more QBs under the era averages than the 2010+ era.

As for RBs and WRs? The sample size is small, but the last column for the 95-09 era doesn’t look good at 80%. That’s actually misleading because 2 of of the 4 were really close to the era average rush yards- Eddie George was 10 yards shy and Ron Dayne was just 2 yards short.

The jump in “era averages” is an interesting story as well. All 3 offensive positions that have won since 1995, have seen significant jumps in era average positional output. The faster paced game and more frequent pass-heavy offenses likely contribute to the statistical increase, but could be to blame for the RB’s lack of success at coming home with the award.

Creating your best Heisman Future

Judging by the findings in the last section, we can assume that the current era’s Heisman voters do fill out their ballots based on stats at least a little more than the ’95-09 voters.

In order to create your best Heisman future lets go over some historical trends. *I used modern day conferences for categories because while the previous conferences listed on trophies don’t change, the pedigree and respect, which can influence voting, for the program follows into the next conference.

  • Since 1970: QBs have won 52.7% of Heisman Trophies, RB’s- 38.2%, WR’s-7.3% (I Classified Travis Hunter as a WR)
  • Modern day SEC and Big Ten account for 83.3% of Heisman winners since 1995 (25/30)
  • QB’s have won 38.2% of Heisman trophies since 1995
  • Only 6 RB’s have won the Heisman since ’95, 3 from the modern SEC and 3 from the modern Big Ten

There’s a check list you should complete if you are betting solely on the stats. Let’s break it down from big to small while including the 2010+ era statistical averages.

  • Player should be in SEC/Big Ten (56.7% winners since ’95)
  • For QB’s: (38.2% Heismans since ’95)
    • Pass for at least 4,232 yards
      • If not met, needs to be real rushing threat: >1k yards
    • Throw at least 40 TDs
    • Have a completion percentage >64.6%
    • Throw less than 8 INTs
  • Bonus points if they play for Alabama, Oklahoma, or USC (each have 4 winners since ’95)
  • For RB’s: rush for at least 2k yards and 28 TDs
  • For WR’s: record over 1,550 receiving yards and 19 TDs
  • Blanket Statement: in the super conference era, Ashton Jeanty proved it’s nearly impossible to win a Heisman from the G5. You almost certainly need to be on a Power 4 team and a top 30 one too.

Which players in 2025 fit these criteria the best?

Barry’s Best Heisman Picks

I could create a list of my top picks solely using the statistical criteria above, but it narrows down to suggest you should only bet on SEC QBs. It’s the safest pick historically, but you have to believe in your selection. Every evaluation needs the statistical analysis + the eye test to be correctly & completely evaluated. I stay close to the trends in my selections but take some liberties. *In no Order

Garrett Nussmeier- QB, LSU

Nussmeier was one of the BCR’s top QBs last season, rated in Tier 1, and within the top 5 all but 2 weeks. Coming into 2025, he meets some of the criteria listed above: SEC, QB, >64% completion and there’s pretty good reason to believe he can meet the era average yards and TDs this season- threw for 4,052 & 29 in ’24. I’d contend his WR room got even got better this offseason too as he now has 2 WRs with at least one 800+ yard receiving season and 1 WR with two 500+ receiving yard seasons. The one area Nussmeier has to improve is the turnovers as he lead the SEC with 12 INTs, including four 2+ INT games. He will have his spotlight games to establish his “Heisman Moment,” and he’ll be the best player on a team expected to be in the playoff race all season.

Jeremiah Smith- WR, Ohio State

While the statistical trends don’t favor a WR hoisting the Heisman, Smith could be the outlier. Putting up 1,315 yards and 14 TDs certainly puts the true sophomore on track to surpass the era averages in 2025. While he has to settle in to a completely different feel: new OC and new, inexperienced QB, Smith has one less target to share with. Emeka Egbuka was a necessity for the Buckeyes last year with over 1k yards, but he likely kept Jeremiah Smith from reaching era averages (1,550 & 19 TDs) as an 18 year old true freshman. It’s not unfathomable that this WR1 could put up close to 2k yards and 20+ TDs in a CFP run. Bonus points for him as he’s on a top 10 team and likely CFP participant. Don’t be surprised if you see him in New York come December.

Cade Klubnik- QB, Clemson

Currently a top 5 Heisman favorite, this shouldn’t surprise you. The trends tell us Klubnik is a long shot to win even with a good season: outside of the SEC or Big Ten, completed less than 64% of passes, was 600 yards shy of the passing yards era total, and threw for 36 TDs. The main driver of the Klubnik hype has to do with his previous improvements each season under OC Garrett Riley. In year 1 he appeared in 10 games with 61%/697yds/2 TDs. But from year 2 to 3, Klubnik increased his yards by 800, completion percentage by 3%, nearly doubled his passing TDs, and rushed for 460 yards. We could see another leap from Klubnik, likely smaller than years 2 to 3. He returns his top 3 receivers (2,263yds & 21TDs in ’24). It’s still favorable because he is a QB and will be leading his team as a favorite in his conference to get the auto bid to the CFP.

Drew Allar- QB, Penn State

Currently a top 10 Heisman favorite, Drew Allar looks to lead the BCR’s #1 preseason team to another CFP semifinal. Allar’s senior season has a lot to be excited about. From years 2 to 3, he threw nearly the same amount of attempts, but in year 3 he improved his passing yards by nearly 700 and completion percentage by 6.4%. His passing touchdowns decreased by 1, but overall he had a very good season also adding 300 yards on the ground. Every big statistical category needs improvement, and there’s good reason to believe it can happen. A major reason for Allar’s progression is OC Andy Kotelnicki who helped Lance Leipold build offenses at Kansas. Allar gets another year under the OC and the weapons in the passing game couldn’t have gotten worse. In the CFP Semifinal vs Notre Dame, no Penn State WR recorded a reception. While Tyler Warren is gone, they got two serious WR’s in Trebor Pena and Kyron Hudson. The RB room is the best in the nation and can take the burden from Allar having to win games himself + be weapons in the passing game.

LaNorris Sellers- QB, South Carolina

A 6-0 regular season finish and stellar play including 2-300 yard passing games and 166 yards on the ground at Clemson skyrocketed Sellers to offseason Heisman talk. An early season injury in the LSU game stifled his production potential for the season, so Sellers didn’t come close to the era averages in pass yards or TDs. Seemingly a long shot by the stats, the redshirt sophomore has big play ability with his legs, bringing flashes of Manziel which helps his campaign. The WR room stays intact and maybe even improved. A healthy Sellers could easily increase his pass yards to >3k but he’d likely need close to 1k on the ground. Sellers reminded me of Adrian Martinez’s freshman year at Nebraska and the stats of their first full season are almost exactly the same:

Martinez (2018): 2,617 Passing/17 TDs/8 INTS + 629 rushing & 8 TDs

Sellers (2024): 2,534 Passing/18 TDs/7 INTs + 674 rushing & 7 TDs

John Mateer- QB, Oklahoma

An SEC newcomer, Mateer ended up at a program with a rich and recent Heisman history. From 2016-2019, Oklahoma had 2 winners, a 3rd place finisher, and a 2nd place finisher. If there’s any pull with voters, maybe that stretch nudges some to favor the Sooners QBs. Mateer finished up his season at Washington State with a pretty good resume justifying Heisman conversation this offseason. He was the perfect blend of the 2010+ era with 3100 pass yards and nearly 900 on the ground, racking up 46 total TDs. Finishing as a Tier 2 QB in the BCR proves that excellent play last season. But this season may bring some skepticism as he joins the SEC. Not including FCS opponents, he played 5 teams that ended .500 or better in 2024. Below is the composition of those 5 games as a % of total season stats.

  • 40% of his pass yards
  • 28% of his passing TDs
  • 86% of his INTs
  • 54% rush yards & 33% of rushing TDs

He comes into a more difficult conference but keeps his OC and will have better talent around him at every position.

Jeremiyah Love- RB, Notre Dame

This pick is a complete uphill climb for so many reasons. From 2014-2017, the RB position had a run we hadn’t seen since the early 2000s. There was the lone RB winner in 2015, but three 2nd place finishes. Only 1 RB since 2017 has finished Top 3- 2024 Ashton Jeanty. Last season alone makes this the most difficult argument to make for any RB to win the award as Jeanty put up the 2nd most rush yards in a single season and was the award’s runner up. It’d be pretty difficult to give the award to another RB unless they come close or are on an elite program with a national brand. Enter Jeremiyah Love. Notre Dame’s last Heisman finalist was their last national championship appearance with Manti Te’o in 2012. After last years run, the public’s love for HC Marcus Freeman, and another elite caliber team, Love could be in contention. In my opinion he’s the nation’s best RB, but his numbers weren’t the historic era standard in 2024. With 1300 scrimmage yards and 19 TDs, Love needs massive improvement in 2025 but he’s part of a very popular program. He will be healthier to start this season than he was the last 4 games in 2024.

Miller Moss- QB, Louisville

Jeff Brohm’s track record is elite: 2x FBS leading passer at Western Kentucky- Brandon Doughty and 5th leading FBS passer in 2016- Mike White. Inconsistencies and injuries hit QB rooms at Purdue, but in each year without a clear starter: ’17, ’19, ’21, his room’s reached 3500+ passing. ’18 and ’22 had clear QB1’s, both threw over 285 yds/game. He’s done similar at Louisville, but not at the “gunslinging” rates from West Lafayette. Brohm gets maybe the most talented QB of his career in Miller Moss. Moss fell victim to a coach “needing a spark” to save his job last season at USC. Moss played in 9 games, recording six 280+ yard passing games with a 14:6 TD to INT ratio in the six. He was on pace for 3300+ yards and 25 TDs before the switch up. With Brohm’s track record, we could see a massive improvement from his 2024 pace in every category. His RB room is an upgrade from 2024 and will take pressure off of him. The WR room isn’t a liability either, he will see an improvement in 2025.

Josh Hoover- QB, TCU

After finishing 2024 in the top 3 of the BCR QB metrics, Hoover should be higher on people’s Heisman boards. He enters 2025 as the BCR’s #2 QB in college football. In his 2024 season, he was pretty close on the era’s passing averages: 3,949 yards. The biggest improvements he needs in 2025 are equally in the scoring and turnover numbers. Historical averages tell us he needs to add double digit touchdowns and cut interceptions by at least half. Hoover had 4 WRs of 600+ yards and lost 3 of them- the 1st, 3rd, and 4th in receiving yards. That will be Hoover’s biggest obstacle to at least match last season’s yardage totals. He’s a QB, but outside the favorable conferences and lacks some statistical necessities. If you’re betting on the TCU QB, its a real “the chicken or the egg” situation. Do you think he made the receivers better or they carried water for him?

Fernando Mendoza- QB, Indiana

Mendoza transferred to Indiana in the winter portal. By being in the Big Ten and a QB, the trends inch in his favor. The stats are where the trends return to the mean. In 11 games Mendoza put up 3k passing, 16 TDs and 6 INTs, but is way above era average completion percentage with 68.7%. The former Cal QB was on pace for 3500+ yards and 20+ TDs, so a pretty big 3rd year increase is necessary for serious Heisman talk. Luckily he has a solid receiving room to build off of. Elijah Surratt’s 2024 receiving yards fell just 22 yards shy of Cal’s combined receiving totals from WR1 & 2 in 2024. He’ll have a pretty good WR2 with Omar Cooper Jr.’s near 600 yard season in ’24. The biggest question mark on whether the production jump is possible is up to the coaches. Last Fall, Indiana QB Kurtis Rourke threw 26 attempts/game while Mendoza threw 35 attempts/games at Cal. Remaining at 35 attempts probably guarantees an increase, but around 25/game makes the production increase unlikely.

Ryan Williams- WR, Alabama

Another rising true sophomore WR resides in Tuscaloosa. His 2024 stats were very far from the necessary era averages: 865 yards and 8 TDs. This is a long shot. WR Travis Hunter won stacking up 1,258 receiving yards & 15 TDs and you could argue he wouldn’t have won had it not been for the extra boost he got from defensive play. Devonta Smith eclipsed 1800 yards and 23 TDs for his Heisman. Many drew comparisons to Jeremiah Smith at Ohio State. While the total stats weren’t close, the per reception stats were. Ryan Williams actually had a higher yards per reception and TD% was 16.7% to Smith’s 19.7%. Another reason for the stat difference was Jalen Milroe’s running ability. It took opportunities from Williams, recording nearly 30 less receptions than Smith. This included a stretch where he had 3 receptions or less from November 1st until the end of the season. The true sophomore gets a new QB, but also a new OC in Ryan Grubb who coached DeBoer’s lethal passing attack during Washington’s runner up season in 2023. Increase in output is coming in 2025.

Defensive Players (extreme long shots)

Whit Weeks (LB, LSU)- a full-time linebacker would have to come close to Manti Te’o’s 2012 Heisman runner up season. It would be a tall task, but Weeks had some similar production last fall.

  • 2012 Te’o: 113 Tackles, 6 TFL, 7 INTs, 1.5 Sacks.
  • 2024 Weeks: 125 Tackles, 10 TFL, 1 INT, 3.5 Sacks

Caleb Downs (S, Ohio State)- Downs is already considered the best defensive player in college football so that helps his campaign at least in the fact of being widely respected. Statistically the best comparisons are Charles Woodson and Travis Hunter. The statistical crown jewel he’d need is interceptions: Woodson had 7, Hunter had 4, and Downs recorded 2 last season.

Conclusion

There’s a ton of data out there about Heisman winners. Some of the trends can make the decision making easier in determining a preseason Heisman favorite, placing a futures bet, or the trends can just help you decide which Heisman band wagon you’ll hitch yourself to come kickoff week 0.

I could’ve made a paragraph for every single QB in the nation, and likely 3 paragraphs for the favorites according to the sportsbook. Some may ask why I didn’t choose to cover just the top 10 favorites. A couple reasons: First, I relied on my BCR metrics for players and QBs so if you weren’t a good statistical producer last season, you weren’t considered a favorite. Second, think back to a time the preseason Heisman favorite actually won the award. Try looking up, “Preseason Heisman Favorites *Year*” and see where some of those guys ended up. It’s not impossible, but if you weren’t a statistical producer in 2024 or in the top portion of the BCR’s metrics last season, I didn’t feel like covering them.

My Heisman Finalists:

1. Cade Klubnik | 2. Garrett Nussmeier | 3. Jeremiah Smith

Posted:

Updated:

Member of The FWAA

*If viewing on mobile device, click icon near URL along bottom of screen. Hit the smaller “A” icon until text fits screen