NBA Prospect Rating


With the NBA draft lottery this Sunday, I wanted to write a page on what value the BCR Mock draft/prospect rating has in evaluating players. I’ve already updated my mock draft recently, but it’ll be adjusted again after the lottery order is finalized. See mock draft here and methodology here.

  1. The Importance of a top 9 Pick
  2. Prospect Rating
  3. Successes of the BCR P.R
    1. Class Status
    2. eFG%
    3. Freshman Status & eFG%
  4. Findings of the 2026 Draft?
  5. Outside the Top 10

The Importance of a top 9 Pick

The teams with the most to lose in the draft is the top 9 picks. Because if you’re #10, 11, 12-14 pick doesn’t pan out, it may look bad, but no one’s going to crucify the team as hard as if that player was taken top 3. Ask the Hawks. Or the Bulls.

Those top 9 picks are the best chances at getting a “star player”. With the help of reddit user Steven_John_Nash’s post from 2014, I quantified the importance of these picks. By incorporating extra data from the 2012-2022 drafts onto the reddit posts’ data, here’s what I found.

The chances of drafting an All Star by draft position:

-1st overall: 33 of the last 42 #1 picks were at least a 1x All Star (79%)

-2nd overall: 17 of the last 42 #2 picks were at least a 1x All Star(40%)

-3rd overall: 22 of the last 42 #3 picks were at least a 1x All Star (52%)

In addition to the data on top 3 picks, the last 11 drafts resulted in 99 players taken in the top 9. 32 of the 99 draft picks became All Stars. Of the 32 All Stars, 10 came from picks 4-9 (31%).

I didn’t take the time to count exactly how many All Stars came from players drafted pick 10+ but I can say that the average number of All Stars per draft from 2012-2022 was 5, with an average of 3 coming from the top 9 picks.

That’s a lot to take in. Basically, you should absolutely want a top 9 pick and really have to nail it. And admittedly, the All Star voting isn’t the most efficient way to evaluate a player, but All Stars are marketable, and marketable means money and interest. So it’s important to get one for a franchise, and even better if they were drafted to that team. Take the Bulls for instance, their last All Star who was drafted by the team was Jimmy Butler in 2017 (drafted 2011). That was the last time the Bulls were relevant (sorry, not sorry).


Prospect Rating

In all this, where does the BCR Prospect Rating (BCR P.R) come into play? The BCR P.R isn’t necessarily good “at the mean” of picking the top 30 players. What I mean by that is that the BCR swings big, either hitting a home run or striking out. There’s lots of guys who didn’t last in the NBA, or maybe didn’t even make the NBA, because their evaluation was based a lot on their college game. And as we know, the college game isn’t a clear translation to the NBA, regardless of dominance.

For this experiment, I only used prospects with a rating of 39.49 or greater. Based on my results from the last 16 draft classes, prospects with this range were almost always drafted in the lottery (top 14). In evaluating “hits” and “misses” amongst the BCR’s highest rated prospects, I didn’t want to use All Stars as the metric because the 24 selections each season often have multiple repeats and the voting process has changed a lot. Instead I wanted to use career average PPG. More specifically, I layered the criteria from 10ppg, 15, 20, 24+ based on a few other variables.


Successes of the BCR P.R

A quick google search of average career points per game for top 10 picks gives you an answer from 10-15 points. Most frequently, the answer is 10. If true, the BCR P.R already has a very slight edge with the average ppg at 11.1. The chart below takes into account the 120 prospects rated 39.49+ since 2009, their NBA career average points per game and the percentage of players that averaged >10, 15, 20, and 24+ ppg.

Another way to read this chart is that if your team drafted a player with a rating >39.49, they have a 55.0% chance at scoring 10+ppg, 28.3% of 15+, 10% of 20+, and 4.2% of 24+ for their career.

Class Status

With 120 prospects at 39.5+ since 2009, the average # of prospects per draft year is about 7. For a GM, the issue remains that picking the best one of the 7 is still quite the gamble. So, what are some other variables we could incorporate to reduce the sample size in attempts to identify the true quality? Class status of the prospect plays a major key.

The value in drafting younger players is evident in the next two visuals. (Class = Class standing of prospect when drafted. Fr= Freshman & Avg Pts = NBA Career PPG Avg)

In the 2025-2026 regular season, 216 players averaged over 10ppg. With the BCR’s analysis, a draft pick that has a rating 39.5+ and is a freshman, has an extremely high likelihood (80.4%) of averaging 10+ ppg for their career, or being a near top 200 scorer in the league and a 45% chance of a top 100 scorer at the age of 18-20.

eFG%

The best available option is to take a freshman fitting the rating threshold, but what if its a more senior class? Take the BCR’s 2020 ratings, only 2 of the top 9 prospects were freshmen. There needs to be some other variable to take the place when a freshman isn’t available to pick. In this case, I tested the outcome based on effective field goal percentage (eFG%). The difference between FG% and eFG% is that 3pt shots are valued higher in eFG% to compensate for difficulty of shot. It basically aides in making evaluations a more even playing field so that 3pt shooters aren’t compared on the same metric that a 7 foot rim player is at 57% from the field.

Under this criteria, the BCR prospect rating’s edge is still evident.

For prospects >39.5 and has a eFG 53%+ in their most recent college season, nearly 60% averaged over 10ppg their career.

Freshman Status & eFG%

By adding both variables of Freshman status and eFG% independently, there’s some pretty big signs that could support why a player is selected at their pick. But what if we added both variables into the equation?

We would get an almost certainty (85%) that a prospect with an above threshold rating, >53% eFG in college, and freshman status, would average over 10ppg. The issue? The sample size is very small, averaging to less than 2 per draft the last 16 seasons. Maybe that just proves those must be the most sought after guys- perhaps ones worth tanking for. Some recents who met that criteria: Cooper Flagg, Dylan Harper, Kon Knueppel, Brandon Miller, Evan Mobley, Onyeka Okongwu, and Zion Williamson.

Overall I’d argue the BCR has significant value in grading players in the draft. Two counter arguments came to mind when writing: are points the best indicator of value and is the bar too low? I answer no to both questions. There’s a lot more to the NBA than pure scorers. Rudy Gobert comes to mind. Secondly, maybe measuring if a top 10 pick becomes a 10ppg scorer is a low standard, but it’s a good start. Less than 50 players averaged over 20ppg this season and 20 averaged 24+. That accounts for 10% and 4% of the entire league. With the BCR P.R test metrics above, the chances a criteria-meeting-prospect has of achieving the same feats is about the same, if not greater.


Findings of the 2026 Draft?

Using all these variables can be useful in determining the best prospects in next month’s draft. This season, 10 players were rated >39.5. 8 had a eFG% >53%. 7 are freshman. 5 players met all criteria, in order of highest rating:

  1. Cameron Boozer- Duke
  2. AJ Dybantsa- BYU
  3. Darius Acuff Jr.- Arkansas
  4. Caleb Wilson- North Carolina
  5. Keaton Wagler- Illinois

The five listed above are what the BCR would label as “can’t miss prospects.” And based on the impact of variables, a freshman has the better chance of being a higher scorer, so the next tier would be freshman that didn’t meet the eFG% criteria. That includes:

  1. Ebuka Okorie- Stanford
  2. Kingston Flemings- Houston

Then a small divide, followed by non-freshman with the eFG% criteria:

  1. Tyler Tanner- Vanderbilt
  2. Labaron Philon- Alabama
  3. JT Toppin- Texas Tech (did not enter draft)

It all comes down to the needs of the team in the draft position. A majority of these top players are guards and not every team is going to need guard play. But there is an evident, valuable approach in the BCR’s prospect rating systems that could help rationalize your excitement or disappointment come draft day.


Outside the Top 10

I only focused on the top 10 picks because it’s the most quantifiable group of picks in terms of achievements. There’s a ton of talent outside the top 10 but drafting in the later positions involves less reason and more of a gamble. Recent guys like Tyrese Maxey at 21st, Desmond Bane at 30th, and Jalen Brunson at 33rd, give off the feeling those picks are more valuable, but they are part of a small club of players drafted at those positions whose success exceeded expectation.

Posted:

Updated:

Member of The FWAA

*If viewing on mobile device, click icon near URL along bottom of screen. Hit the smaller “A” icon until text fits screen