Bunch of Nobodies: A SOS Story


If you’ve followed me for awhile, you know I have no love for the constant, grueling, irritating-argument over strength of schedule. I believe it should be more how you play, than who you play. Win the games on your schedule, dominate everyone- because the best teams beat the good like they beat the bad.

In reality, we can’t throw out the “who you play entirely,” because it does matter. Strength of schedule is best utilized when distinguishing between two similar teams. There’s no point in bringing up strength of schedule between a team who is 6-6 and another who’s 9-3, because if you’re a good team, you win some of those games.

No matter how much I hate the topic, and its ability to control college football discourse, I have to release the BCR’s SOS outlook for this season.

Methodology

I manually entered the schedules of the BCR’s top 38 teams from the preseason 2.0 rankings and measured each teams’ strength of schedule by averaging the opponent BCR of the scheduled teams + if the game is on the road or at home. Keeping the BCR static through each schedule wouldn’t be accurate so I predicted the increase/decrease in the rating each week based on the previous week result. Using the BCR over the last 3 seasons has supported this as an accurate approach.

There’s eight different categories to help predict accurate movement of BCR, L4-W4. L4 = “Large Loss” and W4 = “Large Win”. Where each week’s result ends up on that scale, determines the increase or decrease the BCR sees for a team heading into next week.

Example: A Team with a BCR 20 units greater than their opponent, at home, typically dominates by 14+ (W3). So, the team’s BCR rolling into week 2 increases based on average increases of teams the last 3 seasons who achieved the same feat (14+ win at home vs Opponent >20 BCR Differential).

Maybe the same team in Week 2, plays at home but only has a BCR 2 units greater than the opponent. Historical games show that home teams win small (w1) and thus a smaller increase in the BCR for the next week. For losses, it’s the same idea: lose big = large fall in rating, lose small = small decrease. In some cases, the away team could have a higher rating than the home team, but if it’s within a specific differential, history shows the away team isn’t always the victor (L1 or L2).

Toughest Schedules

As I mentioned before, I felt like the top 38 was the accurate way to measure SOS because I think its only important for good teams. At what point do we blame a 7-5 team’s record on them not being elite vs a “tough schedule?”

1. Texas

2. Oklahoma

3. Ohio State

4. Michigan

5. Alabama

6. Missouri

7. Nebraska

8. Ole Miss

9. Georgia

10. LSU

Some may be rolling their eyes: “7 SEC teams, here we go again.” But it’s true, the SEC has been the best conference top to bottom the last few decades according to the BCR. It’s also important to note many of these teams in the top 10 play the Big 12 or ACC, and the predictive data doesn’t often project them to lose to those opponents. Lastly, this is solely a projection and the season will inevitably prove the strength of opponents.

Weakest Schedules

1. Virginia

2. Texas Tech

3. Houston

4. NC State

5. Notre Dame

6. Pitt

7. SMU

8. Miami (FL)

9. Penn State

10. Clemson

This is where we see the ACC and Big 12 teams more prominent. It’s a validation considering these conferences are a little more top heavy. Seeing a Big Ten team like Penn State is a pretty big “red flag” for SOS watchers. Because while most other conference peers would rank in the top half of schedule difficulty, they rank in the easier category. Their non conference is pretty weak and they dodge Indiana, Ohio State, and Oregon entirely. Notre Dame better be 12-0 with a point differential of +300.

Categorizing Schedules

Here’s a look at where the conferences rank in terms of BCR SOS.

Toughest Schedule in each conference:

ACC: Florida State (20th)

Big Ten: Ohio State (3rd)

Big 12: TCU (21st)

SEC: Texas (1st)

Easiest Schedule in each conference:

ACC: Virginia (38th-last)

Big Ten: Penn State (30th)

Big 12: Texas Tech (37th)

SEC: Vanderbilt (19th)

Average Opponent BCR per conference (#Teams):

ACC: 41.4 (9)

Big Ten: 51.4 (10)

Big 12: 43 (6)

SEC: 54.6 (12)

In Depth Breakdowns

I wanted to provide each team in the top 10 in strength of schedule, with their toughest game and closest game as categorized by the BCR.

TEAMToughest (Game #)Closest (Game #)
TexasH v Ohio State (2)Home v Ole Miss (7)
OklahomaAt Georgia (4)At Michigan (2)
Ohio StateHome v Oregon (9)Home v Oregon (9)
MichiganAt Ohio State (12)H v Penn State (6)
AlabamaHome v Georgia (6)At Vanderbilt (10)
MissouriAt Georgia (10)H v Oklahoma (12)
NebraskaH v Ohio State (11)At Illinois (9)
Ole MissHome v Georgia (9)Home v Georgia (9)
GeorgiaAt Ole Miss (9)At Ole Miss (9)
LSUHome v Texas (10)At Tennessee (11)

Because teams will outperform, or fall short, of their preseason expectations, predictions, rankings, etc. This might not be the best system. But using my methodology at this time last offseason, correctly predicted 7 of the 12 CFP teams.

One of the more interesting ways to read these rankings is in terms of “margin of error.” Who, because of their schedule, has the most leeway when it comes to wins and losses? Texas. And they did last season too. Just remind Longhorn fans that losing to 4-8 Florida left them out, not scheduling Ohio State. Overall, should SOS provide a good reason for a 9-3 team over 10-2? I like that argument under the right circumstances. Should it favor 9-3 over 11-1? Probably not.

Regardless, the creation of the 12 team CFP has actually made the discourse around SOS unprecedentedly bad. In my opinion it needs to be holstered, or at the very least quantified in a more statistically based metric. No more “well clearly the SEC has the toughest schedule.” Even if its truth, give me a real, quantifiable measurement of just how much tougher the conference is. Then we can decide how important it is.

Full Rankings

1. Texas

2. Oklahoma

3. Ohio State

4. Michigan

5. Alabama

6. Missouri

7. Nebraska

8. Ole Miss

9. Georgia

10. LSU

11. Tennessee

12. USC

13. Auburn

14. Washington

15. Oregon

16. Indiana

17. South Carolina

18. Texas A&M

19. Vanderbilt

20. Florida State

21. TCU

22. Iowa

23. BYU

24. Arizona

25. Utah

26. Louisville

27. Georgia Tech

28. Illinois

29. Clemson

30. Penn State

31. Miami (FL)

32. SMU

33. Pitt

34. Notre Dame

35. NC State

36. Houston

37. Texas Tech

38. Virginia

Posted:

Updated:

Member of The FWAA

*If viewing on mobile device, click icon near URL along bottom of screen. Hit the smaller “A” icon until text fits screen