Warning: Strength of Schedule at a critical low


Is your, or a loved one’s, teams’ chasing a College Football Playoff spot in November? If so, you will be hearing the phrase “strength of schedule” (SOS) hundreds of times. From comments on tweets, to the A block on rankings shows, it’ll be discussed as if SOS is the most important metric ever. I’m here to tell you it doesn’t matter nearly as much as its being talked about. But for the sake of conversation, let’s discuss the “importance” of strength of schedule and who’s is the “strongest.”

The committee’s CFP bracket based off tonight’s entries: Ohio State, Indiana, Texas A&M, Georgia, Texas Tech, Ole Miss, Oregon, Oklahoma, Notre Dame, Alabama, Miami FL, and Tulane. I’ll leave out the Tulane in this analysis, as of course no strength of schedule metric will favor the non power 4, and replace them with Utah. I took the average BCR of each opponent each team has played based on where that opponent is rated currently. The results below list the BCR’s SOS in order of “toughest” to “weakest:”

  1. Alabama
  2. Georgia
  3. BYU
  4. Oklahoma
  5. Notre Dame
  6. Texas A&M
  7. Indiana
  8. Miami FL
  9. Utah
  10. Ole Miss
  11. Ohio State
  12. Texas Tech

If I were someone who fully believed in SOS as the crown jewel, all-defining metric, I’d be furious that # 1, 2, and 5 in the CFP are all in the bottom half of the top 12 in the BCR’s SOS. The rankings indicates the teams at the top have more room for error than those at the bottom. A mindset like that in college football should be protested as you can’t control who you play, but how you play.

If a team is going out there every week and dominating, who came to the conclusion that its because their opponents suck? Great teams are supposed to make their opponents look like they’ve never touched a football before. What about the team that’s stumbling, squeaking out wins? Do we just conclude that team must be playing a tough schedule- no, maybe they’re just not that good.

Strength of Schedule isn’t advanced math, its an undefined measurement by most standards. Who calculates it? Who came up with it? Was it wretched athletic directors propping up their own teams or the Commissioner of the SEC? Just like I did, anyone can randomly create a logical SOS variable within minutes. You can use whatever formula you like for it: opponent win %, the BCR variable, or a weighted formula taking into account home or away games, margin of victory, CFP Rankings, etc. you name any variable you want. Most of the formulas could be extremely manipulative and volatile to fit a narrative.

I’m sure you’ve heard the narrative that Ohio State hasn’t played anyone this season? As an unrelenting Ohio State hater, I’d agree-they haven’t played anyone with a pulse. But compare the entire 12 team field mentioned above, and none of them even came close in my SOS variable of touching 2024 Indiana- a team that dominated their way to a CFP birth, winning 11 games by an average margin of 25.6 points.

My main point is: the opponent(s) isn’t, and shouldn’t be, the end-all, be-all determinant of a team’s identity. Does that mean some teams aren’t profiting by playing lesser opponents? Of course not, but if you dominate 10 to 12 opponents by multiple possessions, you’re a good team. In the end, the 2024 committee decided it’s about how you play, not who you play. That’s how it should stay. Let’s pump the brakes on the strength of schedule allegations and focus on whose playing good ball at this point in the season.

Posted:

Updated:

Member of The FWAA

*If viewing on mobile device, click icon near URL along bottom of screen. Hit the smaller “A” icon until text fits screen