Big Ten Preview


While all the ratings in the BCR model are statistically rooted and void of biases, I do a lot of prep work in the offseason. I usually purchase multiple preseason magazines (Pick Six & Phil Steele), stay up to date on teams and conferences via fan sites, and when I can find it, watch some film. I’m nowhere near an expert, but I love college football and enjoy diving into everything about it. Here is my conference preview for the Big Ten. It is broken into two parts: BCR preview only and the product of my offseason prep work.

  1. BCR Preview- Team Ranks
  2. Total Preview
    1. BUYING
    2. SELLING
    3. Undecided
  3. Predictions

BCR Preview- Team Ranks

TEAMOVROFFDEF
Oregon121
Ohio State232
Indiana343
USC414
Washington555
Nebraska668
Penn State7710
Michigan8117
Iowa9105
Illinois10913
Minnesota11159
Northwestern12146
Rutgers13817
Maryland141314
Wisconsin151711
Michigan State161216
UCLA171615
Purdue181818

10 Big Ten teams made the BCR’s Preseason Top 40, tied with the SEC. More importantly, 5 of the top 10 come from the Big Ten: Oregon, Ohio State, Indiana, USC, and Washington. Based off the preseason projections from the BCR, Oregon, Ohio State, and Indiana will make the CFP. USC will finish just on the outside as the 12th best team, losing the final spot to the group of 5 participant.

USC holds the highest rated offense in the Big Ten according to the BCR’s offensive metrics. They return the 7th best QB from a year ago- one of three from the Big Ten to make the preason top 10 QBs.

The Big Ten’s highest rated defense in the preseason BCR is Oregon. The Ducks will have a “no fly zone” type of secondary for the second consecutive season.

Total Preview

This section will be categorized into two main points: teams I’m buying/selling stock in and predicting a few ad lib categories.

*Buy/Sell in no order

BUYING



I challenge you to find anyone truly selling stock in any of Oregon, Indiana, or Ohio State. People are going to call out Indiana as a team poised for regression every single season as long as Cignetti is there. The day of regression will inevitably come and there will be a handful saying they called it. There’s just no way anyone’s selling on any of these three teams in absolute standards- none of them are going to be bad, but sure, there’s some hierarchy in terms of who’s the best contender. That’s why I’m going to focus less on the good and focus more on what could go wrong amongst the top 3.

Oregon

“Championship or bust” is a stupid concept to me, but Oregon’s rightfully a favorite to win the national championship. Dante Moore was a top pick in the draft and returned, he gets Evan Stewart back from injury to pair with Darkorian Moore. It was an offense that was balanced, efficient, and could hang 50 on opponents. Defense was also elite in 2025, returns a ton of talent at all three levels, and the defense gets Koi Perich from Minnesota. It’s a homerun all around, they’re the deepest team in all of college football, great returning production, elite QB, etc.. Worry lies in the double coordinator switch. Just how quickly will the offense get going? Does the defense take a step back at all? Both are hires from within. I’d love to see the results of teams who undergo a double coordinator switch and hire from within. Not that there isn’t any data on the subject, but I can’t think of any examples where that’s taken place. Again, I’m trying to focus on the negatives- the Ducks likely got 11-1 or better.

Ohio State

Biggest worry on the offense is the coordinator switch to Arthur Smith. I don’t buy the narrative that college football is so simplistic and easy compared to the NFL that any coordinator could come to college and immediately dominate. Does Matt Patricia have the same success at Oklahoma State as he does at Ohio State- absolutely not. Arthur Smith is going to have that benefit of NFL talent at his disposal, but I’ve also watched Smith’s offenses in the NFL. They’re pretty stinky at times. The players are there, but week 2 vs a stout Texas defense when you’re trying to ease into full speed, I am not optimistic. Defense should be just fine, even with the talent drain via the NFL draft. There’s five stars everywhere and I’m a really big fan of Earl Little Jr. from Florida State. Again, I’m buying the Buckeyes, just pointing out the “flaws.”

Indiana

Undefeated and 16-0, is not on my bingo card for the Hoosiers, but the CFP still is. Everyone’s worrying about Hoover, I think its warranted. The system is safe for him to succeed: much better run game, better offensive line, but you can’t always fix turnovers via poor decision making. Overall, I don’t worry about the offense, they refilled with top 10 transfers at QB, WR, and OL. The backfield retained members of a top end room. Losing NFL talent at all three levels certainly doesn’t help. And really that goes for the whole team. They lost a lot of key, NFL-level, players. Indiana was a toe tap and pair of missed FGs away from 2 losses going into the CFP. Would that have changed who won the national championship? I don’t know, but if they were that close last season and lost some talent, I could see an argument maybe a 10-2 regular season for the Hoosiers.

USC

“Lincoln Riley is so close to a breakthrough. If only he had a defense.” Is the phrase we’ve heard since his Oklahoma days. Gary Patterson’s hiring at DC is a great step in the right direction for USC. His final years at TCU weren’t great, but from 2015-2019 he lead some great defenses in a Big 12 where “defense” was often a foreign word. He ran a 4-2-5 at TCU and over the 5 year span averaged: 19.5 takeaways per season (~1.5/game), 35 sacks, and 84 TFLs. Compared to last season’s finishes, TCU would finish top 25 in all 3 categories. Patterson’s defenses get after the passer. That adds up well with USC who returns 3 defensive line starters, a four star DE transfer, and the #1 overall recruit in 2026 at DE. There’s optimism the secondary can be a strength but I’d give the nod to the big boys upfront given the previous success in this scheme. USC had just 31 sacks last season, they’re going to need to get after some top end QBs this season.

Offense never seems to be an issue with Lincoln Riley. Jayden Maiava is a stud, no worries about him at all. Uncertainty on offense is replacing the duo of Biletnikoff winner Makai Lemon and Jakobi Lane. Terrell Anderson and Tanook Hines aren’t bad replacements, but Lemon and Lane were just that good last season I could see a little tougher transition. King Miller was an awesome surprise last year and the Michigan game was total domination on his part. After an injury 2 weeks ago, the line returns 4 starters so that’s a big plus.

Schedule: I’d sell 99% of the teams who face the 6 game stretch of: Oregon, Washington, at Penn State, at Wisconsin, Ohio State, and At Indiana. One thing I made a point of this year is not to put too much weight into the schedule- if I like a team roll with it. It’s good they get 3 of the 4 toughest at home.

UCLA

I’m getting in on the bottom floor for Bob Chesney’s tenure at UCLA. He’s currently got the 17th recruiting class in 2027, less than 10 months of having the job. As for this year, will UCLA be 9 wins? No, but I suspect there will be some buzz around the Bruins in October if they’re the 3-1 record or better that I think is reasonable. If they beat Cal game 1, they’ll be 4-0. I still believe Nico Iamaleava can be good for UCLA and Alonza Barnett III had an great season under Chesney at JMU. Nico Iamaleava may not have the stats to prove it, but he was a highly touted recruit for a reason, a lot of talent is still there and I think Barnett’s 2025 campaign could be the blueprint for Iamaleava this season. Wayne Knight finished 7th in rush yards and his presence in the backfield will be a huge improvement in making the offense more explosive.

The acquired transfers on defense are largely unproved outside of the few Chesney was able to bring from JMU. Sahir West is the crown jewel that the staff was able to bring and he’s only a sophomore too. I suspect the defense will be a larger struggle than the offense in year 1. It was horrible all around, but especially in stopping the run. They were bottom 20 in most defensive rushing stats.

Schedule: I don’t think a bowl game is out of the question, but 7 wins is probably the limit. If they start 4-0, they still have home games vs Michigan State and Nevada, to get to 6 wins, maybe Wisconsin at home is the 7th?

Michigan

I bought into Utah every single season because of Kyle Whittingham. I’m going to do the same at Michigan. He brought Jason Eck as OC and Jay Hill from BYU after two top 25 seasons in the BCR. Eck is really the main draw for me because he took a raw talent Devon Dampier from New Mexico and made him into a true star last season. Dampier’s one knock was his turnovers, which he cut from 12 to 5 in one season, while also jumping to Power 4 competition. Eck is EXACTLY what Bryce Underwood needs. Underwood was so greatly underutilized in the run game last year and if the staff can use him in a similar way to Dampier- I will buy all I can. The issue is the rest of the offense I don’t love: WRs are unproven and weren’t reliable for Underwood in year 1. RB, I know Marshall is the guy, the fans weren’t as upset Justice Haynes left because of his late season emergence. But I just have a weird feeling it could be a Donovan Edwards situation all over again: he shines as the #2 back, but then time comes to shoulder the load and maybe it all falls flat. And I know Marshall got a lot of touches as the #1 last season, but it’s not out of the question it happens. 

I’ve talked in 3 other blog posts my admiration for BYU the last few seasons, in large part to Jay Hill. I think BYU’s defense could’ve played well in the Big Ten and now Hill gets Big Ten athletes and some of the studs from Utah’s defense as well. Smith Snowden is a stud in the secondary, John Henry Daley is in the trenches as a top defensive transfer. Michigan wasn’t bad on defense last season it was and they’ll be even better this season in my opinion.

Somehow this team won 9 games last season and now they’re getting even better. Is there still worry that Whittingham has to adjust to the Big Ten? Yeah, that’s a reasonable concern. I like Underwood being a perfect blueprint for the offense to hum like it did last season at Utah, who was 4th in points per game).

Iowa

The Big Ten’s “ole reliable” is Iowa. It doesn’t matter, they’ll find a way to win games and make Ohio State, Washington, and Michigan sweat. Doesn’t matter the quarterback or the stats, great coaching and special teams gets the job done. Kamari Moulton and Xavier Williams return after posting solid production last season. I don’t think I’ve ever gotten excited about Iowa’s offense, but LJ Phillips from South Dakota in FCS is going to be a secret to most. He rushed for 1900+ yards and 19 TDs in 2025. He’s going to end up being the reason I lose hair on Black Friday when he runs for 300 on my Cornhuskers. Defense is Iowa, Iowa is defense. Whatever they throw out will be good.

SELLING



Washington

Everything tells me I should be buying the Huskies: top 10-15 returning quarterback, high returning production on both sides of the ball, who were already good units, and majority of an offensive line returns. The thing I can’t shake is the attempted transfer of Demond Williams Jr. in the spring. Maybe I’m reading too into it, but the details made the situation seem a little messy. And if he really wanted to leave, but was forced to stay via contractual agreement, how much of him really wants to be there? Again, maybe reading too into it. As for the rest of the offense, not many issues. RBs and WR’s seem unproven but an easy 3 game stretch to open the season could build up the rooms.

Ryan Walters proved it to me last season that he’s still an elite defensive coordinator. So, I trust this unit will still be good overall. Linebackers is where the most production, and starters, returned. The secondary doesn’t see as much retention, but Ryan Walters has a great track record in developing DBs as a defensive coordinator. His two seasons as Illinois’ DC provided 3 total draft picks in each 1st, 2nd, and 3rd round, plus a few more who were not drafted but have seen NFL snaps. The offense has its selling point and the defense’s is the trenches. Washington lost 7 total players from the DL/DE room and the reloads aren’t my favorite. I’m not optimistic you can compete too well in the Big Ten if with a weakness in the trenches.

Schedule: There’s two easier wins after October: at Purdue and at Michigan State. In between those games are at USC, Iowa, At Nebraska, Penn State, and then Indiana and at Oregon to end the season. 4-2’s not impossible in that stretch but there’s room for East Lansing being a trap game.

Penn State

If you ask someone why they’re buying Penn State stock this season, their first reason is commonly, “the schedule is so easy.” I agree, but I’m not buying in on teams this season just because of a “weak schedule.” I did it in 2024 with Missouri, who got boat raced in the 3 difficult games they had. What happened to 2024 Indiana? 11-1 was great until they played in South Bend. A good record isn’t the question, it’s the quality of the team. In my opinion, it only sets up Penn State for failure in 2027.

As far as the team goes, I do like a lot about them: Rocco Becht is one of the most experienced quarterbacks in college football, Chase Sowell’s been a great #1 option, and Matt Campbell is one of the most consistent coaches in the nation while working with less. The defense was a little fool’s gold overall. By points allowed alone, it looked fine, but there were definitely a few low points. They benefited from the slowest pace of play amongst power 4 teams on offense, so opponents had less time to work with. Overall, a majority of this team went 8-4 in the Big 12 and I’m of the belief that even a weak Big Ten schedule will be harder than 2025’s schedule.

Nebraska

As a Nebraska fan, I’ve seen more lows than highs. And I’m of the small minority of the fan base that is just fine making a bowl game every year because for most of my life, we never did. Internally I know that’s a loser mindset, but Nebraska hasn’t won much lately. I agree with Matt Rhule- this will be his best team at Nebraska. The offensive line is something I am very excited for with new line coach Geep Wade. He built solid offensive lines at Georgia Tech. This offensive line finally has some Big Ten size and lots of experience. Colandrea is the big question mark. I’m not too confident he stays away from turning the ball over as he did at UNLV compared to UVA. A year ago we couldn’t stop the run, I like the hire of DC Rob Aurich after successful seasons at San Diego State. He brought a stud with him in Owen Chambliss. I truly believe the trenches on both sides are the ball will be better than 2025. 8 wins would be an absolute success of a season, but I don’t see 8 W’s on the schedule. I could write 10,000 words on my Huskers but I’ll stop there- I’m used to disappointment so I’ll sell my stock now.

Wisconsin

Colton Joseph is where I’d buy in on Wisconsin. He lead Old Dominion to an extremely successful season: a 13 point loss at Indiana and a win at Virginia Tech 45-26. They didn’t make the conference championship game but beat one of the two teams that appeared (Troy) 33-0. If Wisconsin is going to have success, it’s because of Joseph’s play making ability with his legs: 2600 passing and 1000 rushing last season. Defensively, Wisconsin wasn’t all that bad. If there’s a blueprint from last season, the offense just has to be a little bit better and the defense stays the same. The issue is that I’m kind of out on Luke Fickell. He’s on a very hot seat and if they start the season 2-2 it could be the end. Paul Chryst was 3-1, after years of success, and was let go-it’s not impossible. Or could a 2-2 start push Wisconsin to be 2024 Florida State or 2025 Kansas State, in which the team has higher expectations or expected improvement and then completely derails? Wisconsin fans weren’t very happy last season and a large jump has to be evident.

Northwestern

David Braun’s tenure at Northwestern has been a great success. He’s not always had the best talent and resources but has found ways to win. This season, I am bullish that Chip Kelly can get the most out of whoever wins the starting QB job in Aidan Chiles or Nicco Marchiol. Last season was a strike of luck not based on who they played but when they played them. It’s kind of a cop out, I know, but if they played UCLA or Penn State later in the season, it’s probably two more losses. Their schedule gets even tougher and they enter the season with a new lines on both sides of the ball.

Maryland

Love Malik Washington, but not a fan of the coach. Locksley stated at Big Ten media days that 2024’s 4-8 season was much different than 2025’s. While I don’t disagree, you can’t say that if you’re 4-8. Maybe if you’re 6-6 or 7-5, but 4-8 means you were likely a bad team that had shining moments, not a good team that just had bad luck. The way I see Maryland this year is how people saw Cal last year: great young QB, with a not so great team.


Undecided

There’s a handful of teams I didn’t write about. The reasons vary, but sometimes there’s little point in writing about the teams expected to be very bad just to pile on. In the Big Ten in particular, three teams come to mind where it isn’t super fair to write a ton on: Rutgers, Michigan State, and Purdue.

  • Minnesota & Illinois- I’m lumping these two teams together because I really like both coaches and am probably biased in evaluating the teams because of it. I like both quarterbacks, both teams return WR’s 2 and 3 from the previous year, and both are retooling an offensive line. I’m more bullish on Illinois’ defense with a new DC and they didn’t lose their best player like Minnesota did. So, I am basing a lot of expectations solely on coaching. They both have a great culture and I just admire them for getting the most out of their teams with less resources than teams like Nebraska. I’d probably buy stock in both, but its more of a blind reasoning than a confidence in the teams given the schedules.

Predictions

Best Team: Oregon

Championship Game: Oregon (W) vs Indiana

Surprise Team: Nebraska

Disappointing Team: Washington

Offensive Player: Jeremiah Smith, WR- Ohio State

Defensive Player: Rolijah Hardy, LB- Indiana

CFP Teams: 4- Ohio State, Oregon, Indiana, Michigan

Darkhorse: Michigan

Posted:

Updated:

Member of The FWAA

*If viewing on mobile device, click icon near URL along bottom of screen. Hit the smaller “A” icon until text fits screen