While all the ratings in the BCR model are statistically rooted and void of biases, I do a lot of prep work in the offseason. I usually purchase multiple preseason magazines (Pick Six & Phil Steele), stay up to date on teams and conferences via fan sites, and when I can find it, watch some film. I’m nowhere near an expert, but I love college football and enjoy diving into everything about it. Here is my conference preview for the Big 12. It is broken into two parts: BCR preview only and the product of my offseason prep work.
BCR Preview- Team Ranks
| TEAM | OVR | OFF | DEF |
| Texas Tech | 1 | 1 | 1 |
| BYU | 2 | 2 | 2 |
| Arizona | 3 | 4 | 3 |
| Utah | 4 | 3 | 4 |
| Houston | 5 | 5 | 5 |
| TCU | 6 | 6 | 8 |
| Iowa State | 7 | 10 | 6 |
| Cincinnati | 8 | 7 | 11 |
| Kansas State | 9 | 11 | 9 |
| Baylor | 10 | 8 | 14 |
| Kansas | 11 | 9 | 13 |
| UCF | 12 | 12 | 7 |
| Arizona State | 13 | 13 | 10 |
| Colorado | 14 | 14 | 12 |
| Oklahoma St | 15 | 16 | 16 |
| West Virgina | 16 | 15 | 15 |
6 Big 12 teams made the BCR’s Preseason Top 40, which last amongst the power 4. The silver lining is that 4 teams landed in the top 15 of the preseason rankings. Based off the preseason projections from the BCR, Texas Tech and BYU are the projected CFP participants.
The Big 12’s highest rated offense in the preseason BCR resides in Lubbock. Even with the offseason QB turmoil, The Red Raiders are expected a top 10, maybe even top 5, offensive unit.
The Big 12’s highest rated defense in the preseason BCR is Texas Tech as well, who finished as the second best in all of college football according to the BCR. They lost Heisman candidate Jacob Rodriquez at LB, but refill of talent won’t be an issue.
*Sometimes the BCR is limited due to its statistical approach. It won’t pick up on mass departures amongst the staff, but does have weighted values for transfer class. One team in the Big 12 review who’s ranking is incorrect due to the non-quantifiable criteria is Iowa State. They lost their program building coach and ton’s of talent, a ranking of 7th is way too high.
Total Preview
This section will be categorized into two main points: teams I’m buying/selling stock in and predicting a few ad lib categories.
*Buy/Sell in no order
BUYING






Texas Tech
The 2nd rated defense in the BCR has a chance to remain in the top 10 behind high retention and quality transfers. An elite duo at linebacker with Ben Roberts and Kansas State transfer Austin Romaine will dominate opposing offenses. The rest of the defense added four- 4 star transfers to their defensive line and six returning members of 2025’s secondary. The four transfers in the trenches combine for 19.5 sacks and nearly 30 TFLs in 2025. That combined sack total alone would’ve been greater than 6 power 4 programs and tied with 3 more- including Georgia. Trey White is the name to watch- 18.5 TFLs and 12 sacks at San Diego State in 2024. Losing Jacob Rodriquez is the only reason I won’t say Texas Tech’s defense will be better in 2026.
Offensively, not many teams will have more options in the skill positions- similar to last offseason. Terrance Carter returning was my favorite retention from the offseason. Obviously getting back Coy Eakins was a big retention and so was keeping the running back duo that accumulated nearly 2000 yards and 20 touchdowns between Cameron Dickey and J’Koby Williams. But as usual with Texas Tech, the portal probably brings the biggest draw: Kenny Johnson from Pitt and Malcolm Simmons from Auburn round out a top 4 pass catchers bringing 2,413 yards and 10TDs from 2025, to 2026. It’s another “pick your poison” season for opposing defenses.
Schedule: There’s a reason Texas Tech has the best odds of any conference-member-power 4 team to go undefeated. Their toughest road game looks to be at Oklahoma State in November, while they dodge BYU, Utah, and Kansas State entirely. Last offseason, Arizona State was preseason favored in 11 of 12 games, I imagine Texas Tech will be too, but unlike ASU- will deliver an undefeated
BYU
The Cougars offense will be backfield centric in 2026. LJ Martin racked up 1300 yards on the ground in route to winning Big 12 offensive player of the year in ’25. Bear Bachmeier was thrown into a wild situation and was incredible as a dual threat QB. Bachmeier and Martin would be welcomed onto 95% of rosters in the FBS to lead as cornerstones of the offense. I’m very bearish on the pass catching options. It’s a majority of transfers, bringing in just 582 combined receiving yards. For perspective: Texas Tech returns two 600+ yard receivers. 2025 showed just how important the trenches are, BYU is one of the most experienced offensive lines with 5 redshirt seniors in the group.
Jay Hill heading to Michigan will sting for BYU’s defense. He lead consecutive top 25 defenses in the BCR and was elite at turning the ball over. Good news is: nearly 70% of the defense returns from a 2025 group that finished 17th in the BCR. BYU one upped Texas Tech with LB transfer Cade Uluave from Cal recording 100 tackles + 12 for loss. Similar to 2025, the secondary will likely be the strength of the defense. Four starters return between the corners and safeties. BYU’s defense has been a hidden gem the last 2 seasons and I really expect this unit to be nasty again.
Schedule: Arizona week 2 could be another thriller like it was last season. They should be one loss or less by the time Notre Dame comes to town on October 17th. BYU will make that a good game for the Irish. When it comes to the CFP, BYU has the same exact path as 2025 Miami- beat Notre Dame and you don’t have to win the conference.
Utah
You won’t find a bigger Devon Dampier fan outside the state of Utah than me. Week 4 vs Texas Tech put a silencer on just how good his season was outright, and compared to his 2024 season at New Mexico. He’s the main reason I’m buying the Utes, followed by trusting the culture Kyle Whittingham spent 20+ years building, remaining intact. Morgan Scalley has been at Utah under Whittingham for more than 10 seasons so there’s a real reason the structure, intensity, and aggressiveness don’t erode.
Utah made a great hire at offensive coordinator with Kevin McGiven from Utah State. His Aggies offense was top 15 amongst the group of 5 in the BCR, with a top 50 ranking overall. He brings his WR1, Braden Pagen with him after a near 1000 yard season. San Jose State lost Kyri Shoes after a near 800 yards season. I’m bullish on the duo given the main focus will be on Dampier and Money Parks in the backfield who rushed for over 1700 last season. I don’t expect another top 5 season in scoring or another top 15 offense in the BCR, but top 25 I can buy into.
Like I said before, Scalley’s been at Utah for 10+ seasons so I have to imagine the defense won’t be all that affected by the turnover. Sure they lose some big time pieces like John Henry Daley in the trenches or Smith Snowden in the secondary. Utah’s had some fantastic players on defense, but it’s not always just talent. In order to succeed for the extended span that Scalley has, talent’s not the biggest reason why. I view the defense the same as the offense, a small step back, but still top end units.
Schedule: It’s a very manageable September with 2 Power 4 games- not something you can say for every team. Hosting Houston in October could be a big time matchup for the conference. If it’s at night, give me Utah by a million points. Give me Utah in any night game actually- it’s an atmosphere I yearn to experience.. November’s where the heavy weight games come in.
Houston
Houston quietly had one of the best seasons in 2025 behind true dual threat QB Conner Weigman. Throwing for 2700 yards with a 25TD:9INT ratio, the ground game was even more impressive. Weigman finished 3rd in rush yards and 2nd in rushing touchdowns amongst all power 4 quarterbacks. Amare Thomas was a true WR1 for Weigman and returns, but what really makes Houston intriguing to me is Willie Fritz reuniting with Makhi Hughes from his Tulane days. Hughes recorded 1300+ yards rushing in two straight seasons last time he took the field for Fritz.
Overall defense wasn’t the Cougars strength in 2025 outside of the run defense. I don’t know how much better it’ll be given the talent that left being of the top performers a year ago- two starters at each level of the defense. I don’t typically buy into teams who are lopsided between offense and defense, but offense is expected to lead the way, and I trust Willie Fritz as a head coach to deliver another extremely successful season that flies under the national radar.
Schedule: The 12 team CFP provides an extreme benefit to having a front loaded schedule. If you lose a game in September, it doesn’t knock you out of contention as it did in the past, and it certainly won’t be remembered as easily in November. Houston goes to Texas Tech in September and to Utah by the end of October. then they have a rather easy November to generate some buzz if they’re only at 2 losses.
Arizona
Noah Fafita is why I’m buying stock in the Arizona Wildcats. We’ve seen QBs lose their #1 target before and have a real regression. Tet McMillian was the nation’s 3rd leading receiver, #1 WR taken in the 2025 NFL draft, and yet Fafita still shined: 3200 pass yards, 32 total TDs, and just 6 interceptions. The RB room remains largely the same, the offensive line should improve because the players tossed into starting roles last year returned, and the tight ends should be a better option than last season with a returning starter. The part that makes Fafita and the passing offense so dangerous is the distribution: 11 different players caught touchdown passes.
Arizona had one of the nation’s best defenses last season. Expect a regression in the pass defense, but the linebackers and defensive lines have a larger share of the returning production. I actually think that plays well for their schedule. They don’t play a lot of the gunslingers the past Big 12 has had to offer. No Sawyer Robertson or Josh Hoover, instead their opponents are expected to have a better run game: Texas Tech, BYU, and maybe even Utah. One thing worries me: if they can’t lead the nation in turnovers, as they did in 2025, how much does this defense regress? As a Husker fan, Malcolm Hartzog will be a stud in Tucson.
Oklahoma State
Eric Morris replaced Mike Gundy and it’s been a widely praised hire. I’m in total agreement because his 2025 North Texas team was loaded with talent and lead the nation in several offensive categories. They finished 11th in the BCR’s offensive metrics, had a top 10 BCR quarterback, and the nation’s highest scoring offense. Morris brought 18 players from that same North Texas team, including the QB1 (Drew Mestemaker), WR1 (Wyatt Young), and RB1 (Caleb Hawkins). I, like many others, am totally bought in that Morris can reconfigure Oklahoma State to an elite offense very quickly. He has an incredible track record of doing so: 2025 North Texas, coached Cam Ward at both Wash. State and Incarnate Word, and even 12 years ago, was the OC at Texas Tech for a quarterback named Patrick Mahomes.
I don’t care what happens on defense, they were so bad last season, anything will be a step up. Skyler Cassity was under Morris last season and has lead two straight defenses that rank top 10 in takeaways. The offense has more of the transfer acquisitions so defense is really going to rely on coaching. The secondary was horrid last season and is nearly an entirely new group of transfers. Overall, I have no clue how well the entire team will translate to the power 4 competition, but I believe the offense will continue churning out points enough to win a bit.
SELLING






Baylor
A defensive coach giving up an average 28+ points per game in 6 seasons doesn’t sit right with me unless it was the 2010s Big 12. He’d probably be top 5 in that metric under those circumstances. It’s led Dave Aranda to a 36-37 record, which all springboarded from a 2021 Big 12 title. That’s my biggest hesitancy in buying anything about Baylor in 2026.
The question we’re all asking is: “is DJ Lagway good?” I’d lean towards the notion that what we’ve seen is what Baylor’s going to get this season at quarterback. Then again, we see every season it’s more and more often the “fit” vs the player not living up to expectations. He’s in good hands with OC Jake Spavital, but the rest of the team is a complete mystery. I thought Baylor was in position to be a much better team last year, so I’m selling stock with the massive turnover.
UCF
Alonza Barnett going to UCF is interesting. Alex Grinch is still the defensive coordinator and that’s a disaster waiting to happen. I’m also a Nebraska fan, and this is Scott Frosts’ team, so yeah I’m selling it in bushels.
Colorado
Brennon Marion is a great offensive mind and his tenure at Colorado will be successful- like it has at his other stops. Having the 2025 receiving leader in Danny Scudero makes me excited to see what Marion can conjure up. The offseason comments from Julian Lewis saying that Colorado didn’t watch much film or do much prep for gam days is something very hard to defend. The Sanders era might’ve peaked in 2024, the defensive coordinator hire couldn’t have been more anticlimactic. I’m selling on the Buffs in 2026.
Cincinnati
The Bearcats will go as far as their offensive line takes them in 2026. It was an elite group in 2025 and return 3 starters with good replacements for those lost. They’re earning some buzz in the preseason Joe Moore watchlist for the nation’s best offensive line. The rest of the offense loses eight starters, Brendan Sorsby was the big one. I’m not a non-believer in JC French’s ability but he’s known to be turnover prone at the group of five level. I don’t know how that’ll transfer over playing in a league up, but at least he has a good line.
Dontay Corleone was one of my favorite players last year just because of his size and play making ability. They’ll miss him, but I think there’s some optimism to be had with the defensive coordinator switch to Nate Woody, whom Scott Satterfield has worked with before.
TCU
Sonny Dykes is a good coach. I’m intrigued by Jaden Craig, the transfer from Harvard. Typically I don’t buy much into FCS to FBS transfer quarterbacks, but since Sonny Dykes took over, TCU loves throwing the ball. His last 3 QBs averaged 24th, 7th, and 17th in total pass attempts. Last year alone Josh Hoover threw almost 100 more passes in one more game than Craig. So he’s going to have plenty of chances to shine and brings a pretty good 25 touchdowns to just 7 interceptions. I like Jordan Dwyer as well, TCU tends to have a clear #1 receiver each year and Dwyer fits the bill. I expect another extremely pass heavy offense.
I’m not a fan of the defense, they lost their best players like Bud Clark, and the 2 edge rushers to Indiana (48 tackles/10.5TFLs/6.5 sacks). Bud Clark is near irreplaceable in my opinion. There’s talent everywhere, even on the bad teams, but this was the 64th ranked defense a year ago and are refilled with talent from programs that ranked 44th and 84th in BCR defensive metrics. Transfers can make a big difference but I’m not sold it’ll be enough for a turn around for TCU.
Schedule: September 26th at UCF is my deciding game on TCU. Quarterback uncertainty and defense are my biggest worries and I want to see if Craig can play on the road and if the defense can travel.
Kansas State
The last two offseasons, we’ve been told about how great Avery Johnson is/could be. He hasn’t broken through yet, but getting Collin Klein back in Manhattan actually gives me a feeling the breakthrough is possible. Weapons on the outside are a real concern if Johnson is going to take that big leap. Klein hired the Texas A&M Co-defensive coordinator, Jordan Peterson, who has little defensive coordinator experience. He’s had some success as a position coach, but this could be a much larger task. There’s not exactly a ton of returning star power from an already middle of the pack defense. I don’t think I buy into the notion of Klein helping Johnson that much in 2026, so I’m selling K-State.
Arizona State
I went back and forth deciding on Arizona State. In the end, I have a hard time buying into a team where I can’t trust the quarterback to win games. Cutter Boley comes into the season as a sub 80 QB in the BCR, which means he was even worse in 2025. But I’m sold on the targets he’s throwing to, especially Omarion Miller. Their top 3 pass catching transfers bring in over 1700 yards of production from 2025. But then the negatives are too loud- a brand new offensive line, the loss of 10 defensive starters, and a brutal schedule: at Texas A&M, at Texas Tech, at BYU, at Arizona. Dillingham is a good coach and he’s got a good staff around him, I’m sure of it- you don’t beat Texas Tech last year without it.
Undecided
There’s a handful of teams I didn’t write about. The reasons vary, but sometimes there’s no point in writing extensively about the teams expected to be very bad. In the Big 12 in particular, two teams come to mind where it isn’t super fair to write a ton on why they’ll be bad. Iowa State comes to mind given losing the program cornerstone Matt Campbell. The other is Kansas.
- West Virginia- In a lot of what I’ve read this offseason about WVU, they are still super far away from seeing results. Most of it contributes to mass roster turnover for a second straight year. Cam Cook from Jacksonville state will by far be the highlight of the team.
- Kansas- Lance Leipold hasn’t won a national title like Curt Cignetti, but to say his tenure at Kansas is anything but a success isn’t fair. Kansas was one of the worst power programs, like Indiana. And he’s made them regular bowl participants. I don’t know who wins the QB battle but I love reuniting with OC Andy Kotelnicki. I’d buy stock in the coaching staff but not necessarily the team
Predictions
Best Team: Texas Tech
Championship Game: Texas Tech (W) vs BYU
Surprise Team: Houston
Disappointing Team: Kansas State
Offensive Player: Omarion Miller, WR- Arizona State
Defensive Player: Trey White, DE- Texas Tech
CFP Teams: 2- Texas Tech and BYU
Darkhorse: Houston
