Week 5 of CBB had some big time matchups, revealing a lot about some big time teams. Some got exposed, other’s stood on the soap box and proved they’re not a team to mess with. As always, we’re going to start with the bad.
Who’s Worse?

Hoosier’s are #1 in terms of most overrated & disappointing in week 5. As an Indiana fan, I’ve lived the last 10 seasons knowing that road games just weren’t going to be won (except 2/25/23, Shoutout JHS- IYKYK). And listen, I am sympathetic to losing road games because it is incredibly difficult to win on the road in college basketball. But the loss at Minnesota last week was a punch in the gut for a team that’d been shooting so well this season, 37.7% from 3, to 29.6%. Not to mention 60% from the FT line & got out hustled on the boards. I said it in my 12/1/25 blog, until you play a game or two on the road, I can’t trust you as a team. Indiana is a very experienced group with a good coach. They’re going to beat up on a lot of bad teams, get another week or two in the rankings and then disappoint.

Marquette is a bummer this season. They had a ton of returning production from a solid team last season, but it’s put them at the bottom of the Big East early. It kind of shows just how important Kam Jones was to last year’s teams. The hot topic for Marquette is that Shaka Smart is playing the part of “College Basketball’s Dabo Swinney,” in terms of not using the transfer portal. I won’t base Smart for not using it, but it could definitely be the root of all these problems. The Golden Eagles currently sit at 5-5, with 2 losses by 20+ points, 3 of them were on home court too. If there is any silver lining, the other 3 loses were by 7 points or less.

I am going to say something controversial: this team’s disappointment is not on Mark Pope. Maybe it is his fault if he hand picked all these guys in the portal to come to Lexington. Last season, Pope’s defining storyline was how the entire roster was a transfer class, who’d never played with each other. That team went on the road and won big time games amidst a lot of injuries and no true point guard half the games. This team has a lot of transfers too, and it seems like some bad injury luck. But again, I don’t put this a ton on Mark Pope. The team has some terrible body language in the 4 games I’ve watched of the Wildcats this season. They fought hard vs Louisville, but couldn’t stop lobbing passes for Louisville to pick apart. Then they blow a big time lead vs UNC at home, and get dog walked by Gonzaga. Hold on against UNC and I don’t think this team’s getting as much slander at the moment. It may not get easier in conference play either.
Who’s Better?

Iowa State won by 23 on the road, vs the #1 team, in a top 10 atmosphere in college basketball. I was Iowa State’s biggest fan last season with that trio of guards. The injuries killed them late in the season, and the offseason losses didn’t have me believing this was a possibility for the Cyclones. I was happily proved wrong watching Purdue get buried. The shooting in that game, on the road, was one of the more impressive I’ve ever seen. It reminded me of Kentucky at Tennessee in 2024- just an absolute mirage of 3s. Iowa State is a top 5 3pt shooting team so far this season so that’s on me for not watching the Cyclones before that game. Purdue typically dictates the pace of the game but Iowa State ran laps around them, the game just looked too fast for Purdue- who I still think is a top 5 team. Momcilovic is a damn dawg, I love his game.

Year 1 of Ryan Odom has been a great success so far and an even greater watch. Sunday’s game vs Dayton was electric. Jacari White was a player I knew would be getting Power 4 offers this season when he dominated Butler last season on the road. Oddly enough their lone loss was to Butler on neutral court the 6th game of the season. This team shows Odom’s abilities as a coach super well because last year, VCU was a “drag it out,” defense will win the game-type of team. And this UVA team isn’t a no show on defense, but they can shoot lights out. They do need to get better at the FT line, some misses late allowed Dayton to stick around. If this team could be even top 5 in the ACC, that’d be a massive success.

Mark Byington’s team is off to a scary start. Their high rating in the BCR forced me to watch their last 2 games- both 20+ point wins vs teams I think are going to be tournament teams in St. Mary’s & SMU. The offense is extremely efficient, but I do worry as it doesn’t seem to extend past the 6th or 7th man. It’s not a huge problem but we saw last season Florida, Duke, Auburn, & Houston all had a solid 8-9 man rotation they could rely on. Either way, the Commadores have impressed me so far this season and this is more of a PSA that I believe this team is top 10 worth with their current play. You’ve been served notice.
