I’m not one to put much weight into week 1’s results. Oregon’s 2024 undefeated regular season was a rocky 2-0 start with wins by 10 vs FCS Idaho and by 3 vs Boise State. 2025 LSU went to Clemson in week 1 for a top 5 matchup, won the game, and finished 7-5. On the other hand, this was one of the most puzzling opening weekends in history. Way too many teams carried a nasty offseason hangover to their first game. It makes for some real “winners and losers” for week 1- not the whole season, but just week 1.
Winners
Texas
I’m not changing my mind on Texas; I think they still have a lot to prove. But I’d be lying if I said Texas didn’t impress me. Texas State was one of the best offenses last season, returned a lot of production, so I kind of expected more than 7 points. Texas’ defense showed out like they have the last few seasons. The offense was the impressing part to me. The run game was effective, the passing game was better than advertised outside of Manning’s interception to close the first half. The ball got spread around, the team has a WR1-A and WR1-B, Manning looked much better overall. I’m not rapidly buying stock because it was Texas State.
Nebraska/Houston/WVU
There were a few teams who struggled mightily, and that struggle will be an afterthought because of Michigan, Oregon, and Clemson. All 3 teams were probably big losers. Nebraska let up one of the worst first drives I’ve ever seen to start the game. Houston was getting everything they wanted and still couldn’t pull away from Oregon State- a team who’s win total is 4.5. West Virginia was the same as Houston, gashed in the passing game. All three were greater than 20-point favorites, Nebraska covered, the other two nearly lost. It all got swept under the rug because Clemson got beat like an FCS team, Oregon dodged a bullet, and Michigan robbed a MAC school.
The Group of 5
Boise State is probably the headliner for the Group of 5 teams after week 1. Leading Oregon in the second half and still within striking distance in the fourth quarter is going to go a very long way in their CFP hopes. If they play that well again, they might not lose another game and even if they were to go 10-2, they’d probably still have a good argument for the last spot in the top 12.
Overall, the number of great games, performances, and wins the group of 5 had this week makes them a winner. We saw UNLV and Memphis are both still CFP contenders. Western Michigan, Toledo, and Boise State played well enough to win, Tulsa did win. All in all, the Group of 5 came to play, you can’t quite say the same for the Power 4.
LSU
If LSU plays even half as good as they did Saturday vs Clemson, the SEC is in trouble. I don’t think Clemson will be all that good this season, but it doesn’t matter who you play, if you play that good. It was utter domination from start to finish. The offense was as advertised, probably even better seeing how great Leavitt was in the ground game. The defense didn’t give an inch even while leading by four touchdowns at half. I was impressed how well it gelled; I can’t wait to see the trip to Ole Miss.
Louisville/Ole Miss
The game left me feeling the best of both teams. From quarterbacks, to run games, to resiliency, to the defenses- all of it made me feel pretty good about both teams. Chambliss continued the unbelievable play from last season, Keinholz played terrific in his first start. The first half showed the capabilities of the defenses, and the offenses just took off in the second half. Big play after big play, it was a spectacle of elite offenses. The game was the best of the entire weekend. Overall, you’re probably wanting a full 60 minutes from both sides of the ball for each team, but I put a lot of stock in teams that can win multiple ways and either team could’ve won this shootout.
Losers
Western Michigan
Western Michigan beat Michigan. In 20 years when my kids ask who won between Western Michigan and Michigan in week 1 2026, I’ll tell them Western Michigan. When I hand out Halloween candy this year, each piece of candy will have a little piece of paper saying, “Western Michigan 12 – Michigan 7, September 5th, 2026”. When I write about Michigan for the rest of eternity, and this season, they’ll already have 1 loss. When they show the “winningest programs in College Football History,” graphic we’ll all know it’s an inflated stat with an extra, undeserved win.
The Big Ten
Not a great weekend for the Big Ten fans this weekend. Ohio State could’ve played only true freshman and probably still win by double digits. Oregon, Michigan, Nebraska, Northwestern, Michigan State, and you might even lump Indiana in there, didn’t necessarily impress. Oregon was in a real position to lose that game, Michigan did lose the game, Nebraska found themselves up 1 at half, while Northwestern and Michigan State held small leads in the 2nd half. All of them were 10-point favorites, Oregon, Michigan, and Nebraska were favored by 3+ touchdowns. I get its week 1, but just a terribly slow start for the conference. I’m left wondering if this offseason just impacted teams a little more than usual.
Michigan
The final result aside, what the hell was the gameplan? I say this as someone disappointed for putting Michigan in my college football playoff predictions, but as I sat through the game I started to wonder if Sherone Moore was actually a good football coach? How did he get 9 wins out of a team with a freshman quarterback, that didn’t have a quarterback coach, and now a full offseason behind an exponentially better coaching staff, and that was the result? I mean maybe give the defense some credit for not allowing a touchdown and holding them to under 100 yards through the air? But it feels wrong to label anything about their performance as worthy of being a ranked team. At one point I thought maybe they were holstering the play sheet in prep for next week vs Oklahoma, but I couldn’t have been more wrong. Just a despicable 60 minutes from Michigan.
Florida State
In full disclosure, Florida State was going to be a week 1 loser regardless of the outcome of the game. It was either going to be a win and Mike Norvell’s seat gets cooler, which is a loss for Florida State. Or, it was going to be about how you could win the turnover margin by four and still lose the game. I watched how they lost, I just don’t know how. I’m sure teams with a +4 TOV margin have won nearly 99% of games- or something similar. I genuinely don’t know where to go from here if you’re a Florida State fan. You’re getting dangerously close to being in a situation like Nebraska- a former power house with little hope of return.
Oklahoma State
Drew Mestemaker and Oklahoma State were dominating headlines in the Big 12 this offseason and they got thrashed around by Tulsa. It’s not a conference game but they have Oregon this week. They could be looking at a 1-4 or 2-3 start based off this loss and it’s really hard to see how last week went and think they’ll be the expected dark horse pick of the Big 12.
