Preseason QB Rankings


Building up hype for our Quarterback is a preseason tradition. The sky is the limit for our guy; he’s perfected every throw, evades every pressure imaginable, and he will most definitely be a dark horse for the Heisman. Who’s to say none of this comes true?

BCR evaluations are weighted on previous season successes, so first year starters or freshman may seem slighted. Think of it more as giving the lowest evaluation because we shouldn’t really have lofty expectations for how much a first time starter will flourish. A small bonus was given to players who stayed in the same system and school, as data shows increased output in players who stay vs depart to a different setting. Below is the BCR’s evaluation of the best QB’s heading into the 2026 season.

Tier 1- Household Names


Darian Mensah- Miami (FL)

Trinidad Chambliss- Ole Miss

Julian Sayin- Ohio State

Noah Fifita- Arizona

Arch Manning- Texas

Dante Moore- Oregon

Jayden Maiava- USC

Gunner Stockton- Georgia

Drew Mestemaker- Oklahoma State

Marcel Reed- Texas A&M

“Household Names” are the guys who are not just the face of their team, but are the faces of college football. Deserving of all the praise, the QBs listed in this section are all Heisman caliber. 3 of them actually finished in the top 10 of Heisman voting last season, while one of them was the preseason favorite. As far as the QB market goes, all of these guys would’ve signed lucrative deals to move on to another program. Oddly enough, only two are putting on a different jersey this fall. One followed his coach to power 4. The other finished as the top QB in the BCR and cashed in with a record setting NIL package. These are the faces of CFB in 2026.

Tier 2- Gold Standard


Josh Hoover- Indiana

Devon Dampier- Utah

CJ Bailey- NC State

Kevin Jennings- SMU

Demond Williams Jr.- Washington

Bear Bachmeier- BYU

CJ Carr- Notre Dame

Jaron-Keawe Sagapolutele- California

Avery Johnson- Kansas State

Nick Minicucci- Delaware

Gold Standard QBs are the tier right below the Household Names. The main difference with most of these QBs is that most have been the MVPs of their own team, while not typically having a top 15 team. A lot of winning is contributed to this group, but only one has reached the CFP. In 2025, all lead their team to a .500 record or better. (only Kansas State finished 6-6). The “Gold Standard” tier’s combined record when starting was: 84-41 (68%), averaging 8.6 wins and 4.1 losses. I’m expecting improvement across the board from this tier. Interesting to note: of the 10 in this section, only 1 transferred schools, Josh Hoover. The other 9 that stayed put are positioned for a 2nd or 3rd year improvement in the same program.

Tier 3- Competitors


Byrum Brown- Auburn

Katin Houser- Illinois

Dylan Lonergan- Rutgers

Conner Weigman- Houston

Anthony Colandrea- Nebraska

Malik Washington- Maryland

Brad Jackson- Texas State

Owen McCown- UTSA

Drake Lindsey- Minnesota

John Mateer- Oklahoma

There’s a bigger gap between the “Gold Standard” and this bunch in comparison from tier 1 to tier 2. Because of this, I felt this third tier was fittingly titled “the competitors,” as a reference to the BCR ranking categories. In due time, the BCR will tell us just how many of these guys can propel themselves into the top two tiers, and I do think there are a few candidates to do so. Mateer and Weigman fit the bill for me. But for the sake of the preseason, this group of “competitors” is solidly in the top half of college football. We start to see the “vets” with 4 in their sophomore year, three juniors (2 of them at 4 years), and three seniors. The guys I’d suggest keeping an eye on this season are the 3 true sophomores: Malik Washington, Brad Jackson, and Drake Lindsey. To be in the BCR’s top 30 QB’s after their freshman season is elite company: Bachmeier (BYU), J.K.S (Cal), Mestemaker (OK St).

Tier 4- Full Picture QB’s


Bryce Underwood- Michigan

Julian Lewis- Colorado

Kamario Taylor- Mississippi State

Mason Heintschel- Pitt

LaNorris Sellers- South Carolina

Steve Angeli- Syracuse

Will Hammond- Texas Tech

Liam Szarka- Air Force

Micah Alejado- Hawaii

Christopher Vizzina- Clemson

“Full Picture QBs” are where the BCR meets an inflection point with the eye test. All are good QBs in their own right, as it could be argued these players could be scattered between the Gold Standard and Competitor tiers if for the “full picture.” This group has been penalized because two important variables are not in play: rushing stats & games played. 5 (Underwood, Taylor, Sellers, Hammond, & Szarka), recorded over 250 yds rushing & 5+ TDs. Games played bonuses are given the more snaps a player plays, so most of the tiers above include QBs with more attempts/games played. Those bonuses taper off after a certain # of snaps, which is seen in this tier. Dual threat ability is in full effect, making this tier one with a little bit of an asterisk.

Tier 5- Unfamiliar Suspects


Maddux Madsen- Boise State

Nico Iamaleava- UCLA

KJ Jackson- Arkansas

Cale Hellums- Army

Caden Creel- Jacksonville State

Carlos Del Rio-Wilson- Marshall

Ryder Burton- UAB

Alessio Milivojevic- Michigan State

Caden Veltkamp- FAU

Roman Gagliano- MTSU

Familiar may not be the first word that comes to mind when reading this tier, but I absolutely love this section. It shines a bright light on the best QBs in the group of 5- unintentionally. There is a slight difficulty adjustment that caters towards P4 QBs. So, if you see G5 guys in the top 3 tiers, see them as the highest tier the G5 has to offer. Tier 5 is more of the next level of the G5. Guys like Caden Veltkamp, Carlos Del Rio Wilson, and Caden Creel were incredible last season. Other names like Nico Iamaleava and Maddux Madsen hold some star power for this group as previous CFP starters. I encourage keeping a close eye on the “unfamiliar suspects” because there are some big time play makers.

Tier 6+ Prove It


R. Tisdale- WKU

N. Kim- E. Michigan

C. Brown- Georgia State

L. Tech- LA Tech

D. DeShields- Kent State

J. Layne- New Mexico

J. Denegal- SDSU

B. Davenport- S Alabama

B. Hayes- Tulsa

M. Murphy- Oregon St

S. Leavitt- LSU

R. Becht- Penn State

K. Russell- Alabama

J. Craig- TCU

J. Curtis- Vanderbilt

E. Grunkemeyer- V. Tech

A. Barnett- UCF

M. Van Buren Jr.- USF

A. Philo- Florida

K. Minchey- Kentucky

L. Kienholz- Louisville

A. Simmons- Missouri

N. Hayes- NDSU

J. French- Cincinnati

B. Edwards- UNC

G. Macintyre- Tennessee

C. Boley- Arizona St

A. Chiles- Northwestern

G. Lopez- Wake Forest

D. Lagway- Baylor

A. Daniels- Florida St

C. Ballard- Kansas

E. Holstein- Virginia

M. Hawkins- WVU

M. McKenzie- Boston College

J. Hecklinski- Iowa

C. Joseph- Wisconsin

A. Noland- Memphis

T. Jackson- North Texas

J. Brown- Rice

J. Arnold- UNLV

L. Winfield- Louisiana

G. Crowder- Troy

C. Pinnick- Wash. State

B. Lowry- W. Michgian

T. Hughes- Wyoming

W. Eget- Duke

J. Raynor- Iowa State

R. Browne- Purdue

D. Warren- Stanford

K. Martin- Fresno State

C. Coleman- JMU

R. Collins- Kenn. State

B. Woodson- Navy

J. Alan- toledo

Z. Chris-Gremillion- Tulane

T. McDonald- Uconn

M. Johnson- GA Southern

E. Colson- UTEP

M. Singleton- App State

H. Hejny- Colorado State

J. Kohl- FIU

M. Hillstead- Utah State

R. Poffenbarger- Akron

E. Williams- East Carolina

D. Purdie- Liberty

H. Belin- Missouri State

A. Flores- C. Michigan

D. Bailey- Coastal Carolina

C. Jones- Nevada

Q. Henicle- Old Dominion

C. Conklin- Sac. State

The rest of FBS is largely grouped together but for the most part its either 1st year starters or “prove it” guys. Two names that jump out are Rocco Becht and Sam Leavitt. Both had declining production in 2025 compared to the previous season. Injuries played a part, but their 2025 campaign just wasn’t the best. And both left their previous programs, thus not earning the slight return bonus.

Other big name guys are grouped in here, needing 2026 to prove their value in a new setting. DJ Lagway, Eli Holstein, Michael Hawkins, Austin Simmons, and Billy Edwards come to mind.

One of my favorite things in college football is a highly touted recruit becomes a backup, or any backup player that plays well when given the chance, transfers out. It’s a brand new process of speculation and unlimited possibilities. Oddly enough the two biggest names that justify this feeling came from Ohio State: Kyle McCord and Joe Burrow. McCord won 9 games, Fran Brown wanted to send Ryan Day a bottle of wine for letting McCord transfer. Burrow- we know what happened there. Lincoln Kienholz, Aaron Philo, and Kenny Minchey are a few.

Conferences

ACC

D. Mensah- Miami (FL)

C. Bailey- NC State

K. Jennings- SMU

J. Sagapolutele- California

M. Heintschel- Pitt

E. Grunkemeyer- Virginia Tech

S. Angeli- Syracuse

L. Kienholz- Louisville

C. Vizzina- Clemson

B. Edwards- North Carolina

G. Lopez- Wake Forest

A. Daniels- Florida State

E. Holstein- Virginia

M. McKenzie- Boston College

W. Eget- Duke

D. Warren- Stanford

Big Ten

J. Sayin- Ohio State

D. Moore- Oregon

J. Maiava- USC

J. Hoover- Indiana

D. Williams Jr.- Washington

K. Houser- Illinois

D. Lonergan- Rutgers

A. Colandrea- Nebraska

M. Washington- Maryland

D. Lindsey- Minnesota

R. Becht- Penn State

B. Underwood- Michigan

A. Chiles- Northwestern

N. Iamaleava- UCLA

J. Hecklinski- Iowa

C. Joseph- Wisconsin

M. State- Michigan State

R. Browne- Purdue

Big 12

N. Fifita- Arizona

D. Mestemaker- OK State

D. Dampier- Utah

B. Bachmeier- BYU

A. Johnson- Kansas State

C. Weigman- Houston

J. Craig- TCU

J. Lewis- Colorado

W. Hammond- Texas Tech

A. Barnett- UCF

J. French- Cincinnati

C. Boley- Arizona State

D. Lagway- Baylor

C. Ballard- Kansas

M. Hawkins- West Virginia

J. Raynor- Iowa State

SEC

T. Chambliss- Ole Miss

A. Manning- Texas

G. Stockton- Georgia

M. Reed- Texas A&M

B. Brown- Auburn

S. Leavitt- LSU

J. Mateer- Oklahoma

K. Russell- Alabama

J. Curtis- Vanderbilt

K. Taylor- Mississippi State

L. Sellers- South Carolina

A. Philo- Florida

K. Minchey- Kentucky

A. Simmons- Missouri

G. Macintyre- Tennessee

K. Jackson- Arkansas

Posted:

Updated:

Member of The FWAA

*If viewing on mobile device, click icon near URL along bottom of screen. Hit the smaller “A” icon until text fits screen