Last week, I wrote about an article from the Athletic on college football roster valuations and the return on their roster investment. Underachieving looks bad on all fronts, but the biggest negative of this immense roster wealth is the effect on the head coach. After the 2025-26 season, the average tenure length for a college football coach was 4.3 seasons. With the extra pressure of a price tag, the coaches’ seat gets even hotter. Just how much does the added information of roster value effect a coaches job security? Here’s a side by side look:
*Coaches of less than 3 full seasons excluded
Week 5 List







The 2026 season may take its first coaching casualty soon. College Park’s whispering pretty loudly, Piscataway’s a bit louder, a little place called Tallahassee hasn’t stopped rumbling for 2 years, and Southern California is wondering if their general is the right man for the army. Lots of movement has taken place in the BCR’s hot seat ratings because of disappointing play and the roster return metric.
“The best coach in football,” is offseason material, while “The worst coach in football,” is the essence of the wild mentality of college football fans. That being said, let’s focus on the biggest faller from the preseason, to just 4 games in: Dabo Swinney.
God answered Swinney’s devout praise with a 3 hour weather delay vs UNC to stay afloat. The BCR does its job in exposing Clemson, 3-1, but ranked 70th. Moving from “Ice Cold Seat” to “Warm,” is in large part because of the roster return metric in which Clemson ranks dead last amongst Power 4 teams. I will never complain about wins, or two national championships, but the data is a little less forgiving when evaluating Swinney.
Warm Seats
If you look at the current list for warm seats, there’s two different shades of orange. The first three names in the lighter shade represent the coaches whose quantified hot seat rating is a net positive. Every other coach after Joey McGuire is a negative rated head coach according to the metric. There’s maybe one coach actually on the warm seat so far: Dave Doeren. Brent Venables isn’t gaining much favor currently, and he signed a big ticket extension 50 days ago. A buyout like that probably doesn’t put him in true danger of losing his job anytime soon. All in all, these coaches are 23-8 in 2026 including 2 undefeated teams.
Hot/Blazing
I’d put these two tiers together and continue giving a pass to Kenny Dillingham and Clark Lea for their recent, very successful seasons. I’ll give a pass to Deion Sanders too. Things aren’t looking great for Colorado, but I don’t see how they fire him given the eyes he brings on the program and how bad the program was before he got there.
Locksley, Norvell, and Schiano seem as good as gone, Bret Bilema already fired his new defensive coordinator after 4 games, and Shane Beamer looks to waste talent at every opportunity. Luke Fickell’s upset last week pushed Wisconsin to their highest ranking in the BCR since he took the job. His team has looked much improved this season and I totally agree his seat has cooled off immensely.
Cold Seats
Ending on a positive note by looking at some of the finds from the cold seats. This tier in particular is where the roster return metric is really showing its impact. 3 coaches moved from rated on a hot seat in the preseason to the cold seats: Kelani Sitake, Pat Narduzzi, and Scott Satterfield. They rank for 40th, 56th, and 66th in total roster valuation according to The Athletic.
What I am about to say about is not a popular take: calling for the job of any coach in the cold seat section is simply because of program expectations. These are all coaches that, by most criteria, are succeeding at coaching college football. Maybe they can’t break through and win the big games or find a way to rally in 4th quarters, but the data shows they’re more than just a mediocre coach.
As a fan, program expectations are reasonable and should be held in the highest regard possible- that’s what makes this sport so great. Coaches like Lincoln Riley or Steve Sarkisian need to produce above average results, beat the big dogs, and establish a true culture of dominance. That’s the standard.





