Fraud Board


What is September college football? Is it a preseason lineup of teams who don’t have a chance of surviving for 2 quarters? Is it getting punched in the mouth and stumbling the next 3 months? For a few it might feel like November, fighting vs the best the sport has to offer. How do we decipher if that team, or this team, or any team, is truly who we think they are? The eye test is a valuable way to measure the team, but are we trusting how good a team looks vs the bottom feeders? Outside of the teams’ fans who’s watched all 180 minutes of Penn State, Indiana, Georgia, Nebraska, Kansas State, Miami (FL), Virginia Tech, Missouri, etc.? Probably not many, because how much does a 28-3 lead in the first 15 minutes tell of what we can expect when the going gets tough?

Week 4 is a significant piece to that puzzle: who’s heading into this week vs their toughest opponent and will they be prepared for it? The idea is to start big, with general observations/stats, eventually adding more and more criteria to narrow the true potential frauds lurking in the weeds. My goal is not to lean only on the crutch of “well this team played that team close and they shouldn’t have, so they’re frauds.”

Playing the bare minimum

41% of the Power 4 is undefeated after week 3 and a handful haven’t played another Power 4 opponent: Nebraska, Kansas State, Washington, Penn State, and Indiana. These teams should look like the best teams in college football because they’re playing the lowest competition. Is the QB looking like an All American? Is the defense blowing up every play in the backfield? Are they winning by 40+ points and putting the backups in by the 4th quarter?

Statistically, what does the BCR say? If a team doesn’t have a high rating, you could argue they haven’t performed well vs lower competition, thus more likely to be a fraud. The good news is: all but Washington sit in the top 11. The Huskies are ranked 37th in the BCR, with some extra alarms going off because of the teams ranked around them. Oklahoma, Oklahoma State, Virginia are ranked ahead, while Minnesota, TCU, and UCF trail by a few spots. All of those teams have one loss. What makes the BCR unique is lesser emphasis on wins and losses, but they still have some value to differentiate between similar teams. In this instance, Washington’s overall win value is still not enough to overcome a few teams with a loss- not a great sign.

In opposition, it’s great that 4 of the 5 teams reside in the top 11, but none of them crack the top 5. Isn’t that almost a bad thing? Indiana ranks 7th, Penn State at 8th, but why not top 5? 2024 Indiana notoriously hadn’t played anyone, but were top 5 in the BCR majority of the season. All the teams above them in the top 6 have played at least one power 4 opponent, dominated them, in addition to lower level teams. Miami (FL), Notre Dame, and Alabama have all played 2 power 4 programs and sit above. A top 11 ranking isn’t excluding the possibility of fraudulence.

Strength of Record

The second test for outing a fraud is a strength of schedule metric. This is different from the previous criteria in which, I’m not just limiting it to those who haven’t played power 4 competition, but opening it up to a broader range of “how good was your opponent, regardless of conference?” Maybe if teams haven’t played a power 4 opponent, or multiple P4 opponents, they played high level Group of 6 teams? I’m thinking of Oregon playing Boise State or any other teams who’ve played the likes of James Madison, Memphis, North Texas, App State, or New Mexico- who all rank highly in the BCR at the G6 level.

The BCR does incorporate strength of schedule in its calculated rating but some people may not think it’s valued enough- some people live and die by strength of schedule metrics. Here is the strength of schedule rankings, with where they rank in the BCR. *Format: National BCR SOS Rank. “Team”

TeamTeamTeam
1. Arkansas
2. Kentucky
9. Louisville
11. Syracuse
13. California
16. UCF
17. Virginia
20. Kansas
21. Oklahoma State
26. NC State
27. Maryland
29. Arizona State
33. Colorado
34. Purdue
35. Rutgers
36. Boston College
37. Georgia Tech
41. Florida State
45. Auburn
47. Wisconsin
48. Clemson
49. Vanderbilt
50. Texas
51. Stanford
52. Texas Tech
53. North Carolina
54. Wake Forest
55. West Virginia
56. SMU
59. Oklahoma
60. Pitt
61. Mississippi State
62. LSU
63. Michigan State
65. Ole Miss
66. Minnesota
68. Oregon
73. Virginia Tech
74. Baylor
75. Florida
76. BYU
79. Houston
80. Michigan
83. UCLA
89. Iowa State
91. Texas A&M
92. South Carolina
94. Arizona
98. Miami (FL)
101. Tennessee
102. Duke
104. Alabama
105. Northwestern
108. Missouri
109. Illinois
111. Ohio State
114. USC
117. Iowa
118. TCU
123. Cincinnati
126. Kansas State
129. Utah
130. Georgia
132. Indiana
134. Penn State
136. Washington
138. Nebraska

This is similar to what I said above, and validation of the idea, that not playing power 4 competition can put you in a spot of inflated belief- all 5 of the teams who haven’t played a P4 team are in the bottom 8 of BCR SOS. I could create some strength of record metric to quantify the SOS in relation to BCR ranking, but since the BCR already takes SOS into account, its redundant. This is where I want to highlight a few teams.

Kentucky and Louisville are by far the two biggest “under the radar” teams for lack of another cliche. Both are 2-1, each having played 2 power 4 opponents. Louisville specifically with a last second game losing field goal to a very good team in Ole Miss. Kentucky may have lost big to Alabama, but the BCR rated the game closer than the scoreboard appeared. Overall, if a team’s played 2 power 4 opponents, won 2+ games, and has a highly ranked SOS, you should consider them closer to the “real deal” vs being a fraud.

Playing with your food

There’s one more piece of the puzzle: how much time was spent trailing in these games, or time spent within one possession, vs obsolete opponents? I mentioned not wanting to rely on this solely, but it still plays a part when taking the other factors into account. Admittedly, I’m not tracking the close games/one possessions for every team and instead going off of memory. Kansas State’s performance vs Tulane last week was rocky. Nebraska’s week 1 victory over Ohio was a one point lead at halftime. Washington found themselves in a one possession game vs Utah State, a week after the Aggies lost at home to an FCS opponent. Michigan lost to Western Michigan, Oklahoma was in real danger vs New Mexico, and even Notre Dame hasn’t played a great 60 minutes this season. I wouldn’t argue bringing up Oregon in this conversation either.

To breakdown even further, there’s also “playing with your food” vs real struggle. For Nebraska, they didn’t look good in the first 30 vs Ohio, but which teams in week 1 did? Kansas State lead by 10+ the entire second half and their offense never seemed to waiver. The total body of work tells me these two were more playing with their food. I can’t say the same for the rest of the teams mentioned above- those were real struggles.

Piecing Together a Fraud Board

If I’m hovering the fraud meter over some teams, there’s a few different ranges for it. Is a team an outright fraud, who’d lose to almost every opponent that is slightly better than them and they just haven’t played yet? Is the team a fraud in terms of inflated stats, but isn’t a below average team? Or is the dominance displayed so far going to be the norm?


These three teams were identified by the data as potential frauds and its worth covering them because they each play their toughest games so far, on the road this weekend. Personally, I’d rank UCLA, Kansas State, and then Nebraska in terms of least to most fraudulent.

UCLA– Meets the criteria of having played 2 power 4 opponents and is 2-1 or better. They play another great QB this week and are currently favorites. Vegas knows something about UCLA.

Kansas State– Not great SOS, hasn’t played a power 4 team, but Tulane isn’t the worst G6 team you could play. Should win vs Cincinnati but defense can’t let up the extended drives they did last week. Thing to watch: Avery Johnson is 5-7 his last two seasons away from home.

Nebraska- Checks all 3 boxes: No Power 4 opponent, worst SOS, and struggled in at least 1 game. We’ve seen this before from Nebraska: win the first 3-4 games in dominating fashion and no show at the first away game. I have to see it to believe it.

Fraud Watch

The data suggests the Red Raiders are one of the most overrated teams in the country. Comparing the BCR to the AP poll, Texas Tech is listed as 36 spots to high (47th in BCR – 11th in AP). Personally, 11th is too high, but a top 25 team is a certainty. I liked what I saw in the resiliency vs a Houston team that came up 6 inches short of OT. Coming into the season Texas Tech was nearly minus odds on sportsbooks to finish the regular season undefeated. If we’re evaluating by those expectations, they’d definitely be frauds. But we’re evaluating based on the last 3 weeks and that’s a different set of expectations and being in the the top 20 is likely more fitting. Minor Frauds

USC also falls into the category of playing their toughest game so far, this weekend. I fully believe in evaluating a team based on the season they’re in, without any carry over from previous seasons. I can’t do that with USC. They turned a small corner last season with a gritty win over Iowa at home and that’s what they’d need to do vs Oregon this week. I’m not too optimistic. Their defense may still be an unserious unit, I mean 35 points to Rutgers? A team who couldn’t scored 22 points on Umass or Boston College? Don’t even get me started on Louisiana hanging 30 on them too. Losing to Oregon wouldn’t make them frauds, but losing by 20+ to a stumbling Oregon at home would.

An easy schedule a month ago looks even easier now. Michigan isn’t who we expected them to be, who knows what happens if USC gets blown out to a scrambling Oregon, and then at Maryland to end the season? They’re going to cruise to a great record. Everyone should be treating Penn State like they treated Indiana 2 years ago. They very well could be in the playoff and then what? They wouldn’t be favored vs another power 4 CFP team. 13th in the AP is a joke, the BCR will have them near the top all season because the domination will outweigh SOS. They’re dangerously close to entering the next tier of teams

Bernie Madoff Level Frauds


I know Oklahoma is not ranked this week but they’re still receiving votes. Michigan is ranked. Neither should be. I struggle to find two tougher watches every week than these two. Only a mother could love those offenses. It looks like a foreign language, the QBs have regressed from last season, and the improved weapons are going to waste. At least Oklahoma’s defense is worth something, Michigan’s defense is propped up by a 2nd half vs UTEP. Overall the expectations for these two a month ago have completely flatlined and somehow they’re still being rewarded. I’d say this even without the supporting data. The BCR ranks Michigan 12 spots lower than the AP, at 30th, and Oklahoma 4 spots lower (based on receiving votes- 29th) at 33rd.

Washington– I don’t think the QB wanted to stay there, there were rumors of Jedd Fisch really wanting the Florida job. Maybe no one’s focused on the season as they should be? Even vs bad competition they can’t churn out a decent run game, Demond Williams Jr. is the leading rusher by 50 yards. The saving grace of the entire team is Ryan Walter’s secondary: 5 interceptions on the season. You can’t limp by the cupcakes and expect to sprint past the big dogs.

Posted:

Updated:

Member of The FWAA

*If viewing on mobile device, click icon near URL along bottom of screen. Hit the smaller “A” icon until text fits screen