We are 3 weeks away from conference championship week. Some teams that will make the CFP won’t be participating that week, so let’s look at some potential frauds now until the end of the season. Some might be frauds in terms of the CFP, others might be teams that don’t have a significant chance to make the CFP, but are wildly overrated. I typically write 99% bias to 1% stats in these blogs and I’ll probably get a little wild and write 97.5% bias to 2.5% stats.

Fraud Status: Low, Extremely Low
I came across the thought today, would a 10-2 Oregon make the CFP? Its a good question, not a guaranteed yes or no, but I’d say yes. I’ve heard the rumblings about Oregon, “well who have they played,” or “we’re rewarding them for beating Minnesota? and Oklahoma State?” I believe they should be considering they obliterated those two teams. “But what about Penn State?” That same Penn State team gave Ohio State its best test this season (for a half) and took Indiana to the brink. And we shouldn’t be focusing on who they’ve played but moreso how they’ve played. The Ducks have dominated with 6 of their 9 wins by at least 3 possessions. They were a tied game with Indiana, under 10 to go in the 4th, away from being 10-0 with a Conference Championship berth on the line. They’re just as good defensively as they are offensively as well, holding 70% of their opponents to less than 250 yards of total offense. I don’t think this team is even close to a fraud, but I heard the discourse.

Fraud Status: Medium
I’m giving 5 big “Horns Downs” on this one. I am a true admirer of defenses and Texas has a top 20 defense without a doubt, but man this team stinks. Are they too high at their current CFP ranking of 17? YES. If it wasn’t for that elite defense, I’d say unrank them entirely, but I’d be more satisfied if they were at 25. The offense is pretty horrible considering the guy at the helm that is an acclaimed “offensive guru.” The offense is 80th in total yards, 68th in PPG, and 2nd most offensive penalties a game. I’m not sure anyone noticed, but the screen pass play Texas scored on Vanderbilt with on their opening drive was the same exact play Texas opened the game with vs Georgia last weekend. They ran the same exact scripted play to start the game vs a Kirby Smart coached team, on the road, thinking it’d work like it did vs a good, but not elite, Vanderbilt team at home? I can really only complain about the offense for this team, the run game has been as poor as it was to end last season. Honestly for how poor the offense has been you could probably talk me into thinking 7-3 at this point for Texas is a successful season. They end the season at home vs a top 3 A&M team, needing to move up 7 spots? I’m not ready to say they’re eliminated from the CFP given there’s a few teams in front of them that could easily stumble. If they make the CFP, this is one of the most fraudulent teams to do so.

Fraud Status: Medium
Somehow Miami beat the best team on their schedule but are sitting at 8-2. There’s no such thing as an off day in college football. The SMU game (11/1/25) was Miami’s first time leaving the state of Florida this season, which is just insane to me. It’s not the same as not leaving home field, but it’s not a good look considering the loss was pretty horrible in my eyes. I don’t categorize it that way because SMU is some bad team, but Miami had no business losing that game. They dominated T.O.P nearly 2:1, forced SMU to win through the air, still got gashed on defense, and committed the 2nd most penalties in a game this season. I can’t help but wonder if not leaving Florida until November had some part in how the ‘Canes fell apart in the 2nd half of that game. I am still a believer in Miami’s defense. In my opinion, they made one of the best coordinator cycles of the offseason and defensive line is elite. What I don’t believe in is Carson Beck or Mario Cristobal. Beck has some pedigree by way of Georgia and playing in big games, but Mario Cristobal is the exact opposite- 4-11 in games after November 1st as Miami’s HC.

Fraud Status: Medium
Contrary to my fraud status, I actually really like BYU. Kalani Sitake is a top 10-15 coach, with the best record in the Big 12 over the last 2 seasons. There was only one other program that dealt with a similar situation as BYU- losing their starting QB in the spring. Despite such a massive shake up, Sitake has gotten the most out of this team and has yet again an elite defense. Giving up less than 56% completions to QBs and turning the ball over nearly 2 times per game is following the same blueprint the Cougars had in 2024. Bear Bachmeier is a stud, and that scramble to win the Holy War was electric. He’s got 2 great play makers on the outside and a capable back to share the carries with. I think this is a well balanced offense, but with some limitations in terms of total options. The defense I don’t worry about: they held the 4th highest scoring offense to 29 points on the road (down 13points from season average). The Big 12 is just unfairly judged, and was set up as a “fraud” conference in the preseason and the conference’s 2nd best team is getting some unnecessary hate.

Fraud Status: High
Oklahoma’s season has made me think of Michael Corleone’s quote, “Just when I thought I was out, They pull me back in.” I’ve turned my back on this team at least 5 times this season. I was “in” when they beat a solid Michigan team. Then Auburn came to town, followed by Mateer’s injury, followed by rushing Mateer back for the Red River Shootout disaster. I was solidly out on this team. Did the Ole Miss game move the needle for me? Okay, yeah a little bit because Ole Miss is an elite team in my eyes, and they had a lead late in the 4th. I honestly didn’t expect the Sooners to win a game in Knoxville, let alone Tuscaloosa, so am I totally back in? Yes, yes I am.
So, why is the “fraud alert” high? I have to stick with my instincts on this one, because I believe teams that skid by week-to-week will eventually stumble their way into some bad losses. Even in back to back wins they’ve won by a combined 8 points, beat a terrible Hugh Freeze Auburn team by 7 at home, and Michigan was every bit in that game than the score indicates. Am I penalizing a team for winning? Yes, but its not just the close wins, they aren’t necessarily excelling in anything either. The Sooners are a defensive identity team, but their offense has been really bad at times. ESPN reported that the win at Alabama was the lowest offensive yards recorded in a win since 2001 (212 yards) for the Sooners. Their PPG ranks lowest of the P5 teams in the CFP top 12, by more than a field goal. Mateer was the Heisman favorite before his injury, but he hasn’t been close to the same passer since, which is a cause for worry. Defense wins championships, but the offense is shaky and this team has been in a ton of close calls this season.

Fraud Status: HIGH, VERY HIGH
This team’s not worth writing a ton about. Good coach in Huepel, but this teams is ranked solely to prop up the SEC. They’re only good accomplishments reside in losses.
