Equal Wins


The College Football Playoff was created to select the “best” teams for a postseason bracket. In my opinion, the committee has failed to meet that objective. That’s a large reason I created the BCR. So in this week’s breakdown, we’re going to look at the best 3, 2, and 1 loss teams as they are rated in the BCR, which discredits the idea that a win is the end all be all. Not all wins are created equal.

3 Loss Teams

There’s 32- 3 loss teams in the FBS so I’m only going to mention those ranked in the BCR top 40.

Kansas State is rated the highest amongst all 3 loss teams in FBS, followed by Oklahoma at 25. The outlier in this group is South Carolina, arguably one of the hottest teams in the nation and one that has let early leads slip away. In 3 games this season, they’ve rushed out to 13+ point leads, but finished 1-2 in those 3. Secondly, South Carolina has only been outgained one time this season- a blowout loss in Tuscalusa. So what’s the catch, why are they still so low? Defense. They’re a lax group when it comes to defending the pass, ranked 6th worst in opposing completion percentage (67.8%). Oklahoma and UCF have had their key wins but also bad losses. Still ranked in the top 40 as a 3 loss team is by no means a bad place to be.

2 Loss Teams

There are 30- 2 loss teams in the FBS. 14 of them rank in the BCR top 40 and rather than covering all of them, here’s a full listing.

LSU
Alabama
Texas
Houston
Tennessee
Oklahoma St
Nebraska
Ole Miss
Florida
Iowa
Wisconsin
Missouri
Virginia Tech
Duke
USC
Cincinnati
Minnesota
LA Tech
Oregon State
Toledo
Memphis
North Texas
North Dakota St
Air Force
South Florida
Army
App State
FAU
Ohio
Jacksonville St

LSU ranks the highest at #7, with Alabama (13th), Texas (14th), Houston (18th), Tennessee (19th), and Oklahoma State (20th) to round out the top 20.

USC, Cincinnati and Minnesota rank as the lowest rated Power 4 teams with 2 losses at 43rd, 44th, and 46th.

This is the interesting part where the BCR works its magic. The difference between an 1 and 2 loss team can be a lot of things: a tough schedule, bad luck, untimely injury, but more often than not, the difference between a 5-2 record and 4-3 record feels, and is, drastic. For the top seven 2 loss teams, no 3 loss teams are rated higher, but Kansas State creeps in at #22 to tell an interesting story.

Teams like Ole Miss, Florida, Iowa, Wisconsin, Missouri, Virginia Tech, USC,- all the way to Minnesota are all rated lower than multiple 3 loss teams. If you’re Minnesota, Cincinnati, Duke, or USC, six 3 loss teams are rated above. What’s causing this divide? All of them either have one blowout loss or a loss vs a poor opponent. Ole Miss, Florida, Wisconsin, Missouri, and USC have all been dominated by 24+ points.

The 3 loss teams seeing higher ranks haven’t suffered a dominating defeat and lose in close fashion. I wanted to cover at least one team from each power conference.

LSU’s offense is exactly what we expected under Lane Kiffin, fast, explosive, reliable. Which says alot considering I don’t trust their quarterback and their best pass catcher has already faced injuries. Regardless, TreyDez Green is the key to this offense. Its not entirely like this, but it reminds me of Charlie Becker’s emergence for Indiana last season: Surratt and Cooper Jr.’s best came when Becker came to play. LSU’s WRs in games with Green vs Without. Green has missed 3 power 4 games and played in 3 power 4 games. In games he does play: the passing is much more distributed, 4 wideouts haul in 3+ catches on average vs just 2 without his presence. While it makes sense throwing another option into the mix will flatten the distribution, it does so without Green becoming the #1 target. Only in the Ole Miss game was he the Tigers leading receiver in terms of catches. His impact is far greater, he might be Leavitt’s favorite target, and averages 2nd highest yards per catch on the team.

And while my biggest hang up is on the quarterback, no one is talking about the run game. In comparison to last season, LSU’s rush yards per game is the 6th best in year over year improvement (88 more rushing yards per game). In fact, they’re the only team in college football to see top 25 rankings in increases of all 4 major rushing categories: Att’s/G, Yds/G, Yds/Carry, and Rushing TDs/game.

While I believe there will be a 9-3 in the College Football playoff, I’m not certain it’ll be Alabama. We’re starting to see the same flashes of this team getting beat then slowly going belly up. Full belly came out as time dwindled in Neyland Stadium. It’s a little different with a true freshman QB, the game won’t be as easy of a fix because you haven’t been through it at this level before. But instead of focusing on an offense let’s talk defense.

The defense proved its the main talking point in the last two games. At Tennessee should’ve been a bloodbath after 2 1st quarter turnovers. Instead the two turnovers were held to 9 points and an interception kept them in the game at halftime. That’s more than expected from a defense on the road. Eventually the levies broke and asking your defense to stay on the field for so long won’t go your way (25/35 T.O.P). Then flip to the Texas A&M game, 3 takeaways and you still found yourself down, at home to an unranked opponent, in the 4th quarter. And it’s not all about takeaways, outside of the Tennessee game, Alabama’s an elite run stopping group (24th in rushing yards allowed/game) with a lethal pass rush: 20 sacks in 8 games is 61% of last year’s total in 15 games.

In the games that matter, defense has shown up. Take out the early season drummings, this team will go as far as the defense takes them.

Admittedly, this is a selfish team to highlight here. By my metrics, they’re favored in every remaining game, will finish 10-2 but are complete longshots to make the CFP. It’d rely on Texas Tech losing 2 more games (games at OK State and vs Arizona remaining), BYU losing 1 more (remaining games: ASU, at Utah, Baylor, at Kansas, Cincy), Oklahoma State to lose 1 more game (at Iowa State, at Kansas State, Texas Tech, at ASU, Kansas). Longshots.

These larger conferences are to blame because the schedule wasn’t as nice to Houston as it is for most of the teams already ahead of them. And their two loses were nearly wins (loser talk, I know). Houston’s a team worthy of the playoff in my opinion. Weigman is one of the most underrated quarterbacks, Overmeyer and Thomas two of the sports’ best pass catchers. The number of teams that win on the road at Utah, at night, is a short list. 10-2 Houston won’t get the talk they deserve

The Huskers are the Big Ten’s highest rated 2 loss team. Considering they might not play any of their future opponents’ week 1 starting QBs, it makes for an interesting 5 game stretch. 21st overall, 32nd ranked offense and 9th ranked defense is the Huskers’ BCR profile. The aspect you have to watch with this team is the run game, which has declined in every game this season. It’s in large part due to injury, but has been supplemented by QB play. With a 2-2 record vs the power 4, QB Anthony Colandrea has been the team’s leading rusher in 3 of those games. His legs make the difference, and will need to continue being a difference maker for any kind of CFP hopes to stay alive.

The pass game requires some work too, with inconsistency outside the WR1, Kwazi Gilmer. Gilmer’s recorded 70+ in 3/4 power 4 games while no other pass catcher has recorded multiple games of 40+ yards. With the run game’s struggles, another consistent pass catcher has to show up. Good news is, of their next 5 opponents, 3 fall outside the top 45 in pass yards allowed, with 2 ranked outside the top 80.

Ethan Grunkemeyer’s playing great football and not many people have caught on. He’s the 5th ranked QB in the BCR highlighted by a 71% completion rate and a 23 total TDs to just 2 INT’s. My favorite part of the offense is TE Luke Reynolds, he’s a very reliable target and one of Grunkemeyer’s favorite connections. The Hokies offense is not short on creativity either; of the 18 passing touchdowns this season, 8 different players have hauled in at least one touchdown, 5 players have caught 2 or more. That kind of trust with your pass catchers is something I put a lot of stock in. The one thing the offense has to clean up is the fumbles, averaging one a game 8 games into the season.

As far as the schedule goes, the BCR model favors them in two games: vs Stanford and vs Virginia, while the BCR estimates a 4 point underdog to SMU and 20 point dog to Miami (FL). SMU is the game to pull off the upset, but SMU is yet to lose a home ACC game since joining the conference.

1 Loss Teams

There are 3 undefeated teams in the BCR top 8, but none take the top spot. There’s little that separates these teams- as it should be. How different is a 17-15 win on the road vs a walk off FG loss at home? What about a win after trailing for 38 minutes at home vs Ohio State who lead for 48 minutes, on the road, in their lone loss. Notre Dame, Indiana? One play, one minute away from a potential game winning score. I’m not lobbying that all one loss teams and undefeateds should be on the same level, because there’s multiple one loss teams outside the top 10. Below is the BCR Rank. Team- # of 2 loss teams ranked ahead of these 1 loss teams.

9. Northwestern- 1
10. SMU- 1
11. Wake Forest- 1
12. Kentucky- 1
15. BYU- 3
16. Arizona- 3
17. Texas Tech- 3

Posted:

Updated:

Member of The FWAA

*If viewing on mobile device, click icon near URL along bottom of screen. Hit the smaller “A” icon until text fits screen