Deep Dive Top 5


It’s been awhile since I’ve written a college basketball blog, but I had to get some more games under my belt before I started confidently writing about teams’ expectations, disappointments, ceilings, floors- you name it. I was asked the other day who my top 5 teams were.

A top 3 came to mind pretty quickly but the other 2 I had to dig deep into who I really believed in. I really over analyzed my top 5. Some of the analyzing was based on who was the best right now. Other parts were on where I thought this team would be in a month from now or where this team was compared to their ceiling.

I think it’s only fitting to start on the teams just left on the outside, with brief reasoning why.

On the Outside:

Iowa State

I was the biggest Iowa State fan last season. I loved their guard trio and they had perfect compliments around them. Then the team caught the injury bug. That is seriously my only worry this year about the Cyclones and why they didn’t crack my top 5. They’re definite contenders and likely my 6th best team.

Uconn

The sport is better when the Huskies are good. They too are definite contenders and they have the type of depth that reminds me of last year’s Florida team. But why not in my top 5? The Big East is on pace for 3, maybe 4, bids to the tournament right now. I mean the bottom of that conference is very very bad. Dan Hurley treats the bad teams the same as good teams but they’re going to get fat by feeding on a bad conference.

Alabama

I’ve said in the past I am not sure if Alabama could ever win a title with their play style, but they’re a top 10 team regardless. I love Labaron Philon, he’s a more efficient Mark Sears, and top 15 in scoring per game. Really you can’t go wrong with their top 3 guards including Holloway & Wrightsell. Per usual, the 3 ball is their game and it’ll need to continue falling to ever crack my top 5.

Duke

This is a very good team, but I am not completely sold. It’s similar to Uconn’s situation: the ACC is shaping up to be awful again this season. The completeness of their team is questionable. Last season if Flagg wasn’t having an A+ game, the team around him was a perfect compliment- especially from 3. I wonder if the same will happen when Boozer has off games. Last year’s squad had 5 shooters >38% from 3, compared to 1 this season.

Michigan State

They should’ve won the Duke game at home & the recent lost to Nebraska could’ve easily gone their way late. Regardless, Izzo still has a top 10 squad and a lot of improvement on the way. They will get tested in conference play and come out on the other side better than before. 3pt shots has to start falling though.

BYU

BYU has the highest scoring trio in the country between Dybantsa, Saunders, and Wright III. They’re very efficient on offense and the defense is top 25 in a lot of metrics as well. They’ve got a gauntlet schedule to end January: at Texas Tech, vs Arizona, and at Kansas.


Top 5

Number 5

There’s a lot I like about this team. Coach Calipari might get some heat from time to time, but I’ve been bought in on him at Arkansas since last seasons late season finish. This team’s athleticism is unique to only a few other teams in the sport and it starts with Trevon Brazile. You should look up his putback dunk early in the first half of the Tennessee game. Per usual with Calipari teams, they’re guard heavy and the talent is endless. Darius Acuff Jr. might be taking the top spot for my favorite player in cbb right now. He is a true play maker and there’s just so many times a game where you watch him and think “yeah this is the Coach Cal freshman guard that’s going to go in the lottery.” Meleek Thomas is no different.

As good as the guards are, and as talented as this team is, it isn’t anything we haven’t seen before. Coach Cal had a lot of teams just like this at Kentucky, some of them were better too. But there’s just something about this team. All 3 losses came to teams ranked higher and on the road/neutral court. It’s hard to win those games, especially when game #2 of the entire season is in East Lansing. This is a team I’ve enjoyed watching. They’re a skilled group and the athleticism just really sells it for me. The SEC is wide open for the taking.

Number 4

If you know me, it pains me to include this team. First off, yes, I am aware they lost by 27 on home court to Iowa State. I watched every second and loved it. Jokes aside, this is still a top 5 team. The roster is too good, too veteran, and too well coached for me not to include them. A flip switched after that loss: 5 straight wins, 4 by defeating Power 5 opponents, by an average margin of 26.6 points. Smith just became the Big Ten’s all time leading assist man, Loyer’s the leading scorer (something they needed last season), and Oscar Cluff has translated well to the Big Ten. That’s all without mentioning Trey Kaufman-Renn, the team’s most consistent scorer. Purdue is a damn good shooting team as well, efficient, and doesn’t turn the ball over much.

Honestly, Purdue needed that punch in mouth from Iowa State. Who knows how they’ll finish in the Big Ten, I’d still wager a top 3-4 finish and a 2 or 3 seed in the tournament. The important part is: this team is better than last year. A deeper rotation benefits them immensely and there’s not a more reliable player in the sport than Braden Smith. And it always helps the strongest whistle in the sport resides in West Lafayette.

Number 3

If you love offense, Vanderbilt is your team. Not only are they high scoring with a starting 5 averaging double figures, the Commodores are very efficient: over 50% from the field, 77% at the line, 38% from 3. I honestly don’t even evaluate the defense that much because I’m too enthralled by the offense. South Carolina, SMU, and Wake Forest aren’t great competition, but all three struggled to get scores on Vandy. Tyler Nickel is the guy to watch, he has to be close to the best 3pt% in the nation. Kobe Brea was like 48% at Dayton/Kentucky and he was #1. Nickel is currently at 49% on 14ppg. I value depth a lot in college basketball. The Uconn teams a few years ago & Florida last season all had multiple options and those options could be the leading scorer on any given night. That’s something Vandy’s been doing this season.

If you follow my BCR Rankings, you’re probably thinking I’m just copying them. But one of the best takeaways from creating the BCR is it identifies teams to watch- in a way. Vanderbilt was one of those teams early and I’ve made it a point to watch them anytime I can. January is going to tell what Vanderbilt is made of.

Number 2

I don’t have to say much about the Wolverines. Their dominance has been well documented and spread across college basketball outlets. And it truly is something impressive. Dusty May’s got a deep rotation as well and clearly the top end is maybe second to none in college basketball. Of their 13 games, they’ve had 6 different players finish as the teams leading scorer. I can’t think of a better transfer trio than Lendeborg, Mara, or Cadeau- all who’ve finished as the team’s leading scorer in at least 1 game. It’s simply been nothing but dominance. They can run you out of the building on offense and if you take too long in the half court offense, you might as well hand the ball over then. Typically a top 3 team is good at both offense and defense, but not always elite at both. Michigan is.

30 point wins won’t last in conference play, but that’s okay because that is a huge margin for error. I can’t remember a time I saw a ranked on ranked matchup where one of the teams was a 24 point favorite like Michigan was vs USC. And I’m not a high level basketball mind in the slightest, but I watched that game and genuinely didn’t understand or think of a way to even throw Michigan off their game. Someone will do it eventually, but I’m skeptical if its anytime soon.

Number 1

As much as I value depth, I value road/neutral court wins the most in college basketball. And Arizona’s early season stretch has not been lost on me. They beat Florida, UCLA, Alabama, and San Diego State on neutral court. Two of the four wins came by 20+. Arizona went to Uconn and stole a game too- a team that’s lost only 4 home games the last 3 seasons. But it’s not just those early season games as they’ve won 8 of the last 9 by 21+ points. I’m big on teams that are a complimentary group or have a good mix of different skillsets with lots of options. Arizona fits that mold. The focus is getting to the rim and they do a good job of it, which opens up looks from 3. And they don’t all sell out on shooting the 3 with only 3 players shooting 35%+ from 3. As a team, they shoot the 3 well, but that isn’t their identity (they’re like bottom 20 in 3pt attempted/game). In this specific aspect, they remind me of last year’s Houston offense.

I am a big believer in Arizona right now. Koa Peat had my attention as an absolute baller since that first game of the season vs Florida. But there’s so much other talent to like on this team and they rebound the hell out of the ball. This is the perfect team for me: complimentary, rebounds well, plays really good defense, and has quality depth. I’d like to see them get better at the FT line. My biggest worry is that Tommy Llyod’s team may have peaked too early (again).


Notables That Missed the Cut

Houston

The only reason Houston didn’t make my “on the outside,” section was because of the close call at Cincinnati this past weekend.

Nebraska

Nebraska is a really good team, but I still felt more confident in the teams I listed above. Maybe its brand bias or previous season successes compared to Big Red. They’ve had some luck go their way, but again still a really good team.

Gonzaga

Gonzaga

Mark Few is one of the best coaches in college basketball. A close call vs Seattle also probably cost them a spot in my “on the outside” section. Nevertheless, Few still has one of the most efficient offenses and an elite defense to pair it with.

UNC

Big fan of the Tarheels this season, with some reasonable skepticism about their backcourt. Wilson and Veesar are one of the best duos in the ACC. A few injuries and a terrible showing at SMU cost them.

Louisville

Early on this season, I thought this Louisville team was much different than the team who got bullied by Creighton in the first game of the tournament. I don’t think that so much now. I question whether they can win if the 3 isn’t falling. Mix that with the ACC competition, I had to keep them on the outside.

Posted:

Updated:

Member of The FWAA

*If viewing on mobile device, click icon near URL along bottom of screen. Hit the smaller “A” icon until text fits screen