Back to back blogs on the College Football Playoff rankings is striking while the iron’s hot. Yet another week and the committee has lost the plot. I wrote last week about the SEC’s guaranteed path to the CFP, but this time around let’s focus on all the different perspectives you can rank these teams, but individually. The committee says they evaluate all these variables in combination, but yet we sit here asking why consider them at all if their value is bare minimum?
Margin of Victory
If you’ve watched the rankings shows there’s a few different things that didn’t make a ton of sense. One of them being not comparing teams because of some “pod” system for grouping teams. It’s not my favorite method and its not super clear. So I read up on the committee’s evaluation process and criteria for you. One thing that stuck out is this sentence:
“The committee will select the teams using a process that distinguishes among otherwise comparable teams by considering: Comparative outcomes of common opponents (without incenting margin of victory)”
You read that correctly: “without incenting margin of victory.” That explains the Alabama and Tennessee debate; they only see the wins and losses as a yes or no. This is where I throw in a comment about what happen to the sport I love, because in what world does the margin of victory not matter in similar opponents? Let’s play through the thought of a playoff spot being on the line with just one game remaining, and the team at #12 or #13 has a big game and style points should matter. Running up the score should matter, 99% of the time in college football. Sure, don’t run it up on Chattanooga if you’re Alabama, but for similar opponents? Hang a hundred on them.
All this to say is that I think that’s the wrong way to evaluate a team and in doing so, this is how the CFP would look like if the rankings were solely based on margin of victory with the spots moved up/down compared to the real rankings.
| 1. Wake Forest (+12) 2. Georgia (-1) 3. Miami (FL) (+4) 4. Notre Dame (+1) 5. Utah (-3) 6. Indiana (+3) 7. UCLA (-3) 8. LSU (+13) 9. Ohio State (+11) 10. Tennessee (-2) 11. Alabama (-8) 12. Oklahoma State (+13) 13. Iowa (+2) | 14. Arizona (+9) 15. Houston (-1) 16. Boise State (+8) 17. Texas (-11) 18. Texas Tech (-6) 19. Oregon (-3) 20. South Carolina (-3) 21. BYU (-11) 22. Missouri (0) 23. USC (-5) 24. Ole Miss (-5) 25. Kentucky (-14) |
Interestingly enough, if you went by this one, singular metric in margin of victory, 7 of the top 12 in the current rankings would still be included. There’s always more to the full picture but it’s interesting to know this is half way there. Secondly, this could also be used as a gauge for who could be too high or too low and if MoV were more prominent. Fun fact, 7-2, unranked Duke sits tied with Indiana for the 6th largest margin of victory amongst the top 25 with +20 point differential/game.
Strength of Schedule
Even Curt Cignetti had his fun on twitter questioning the punishments for bad losses and many have voiced similar saying that the resume trumps all. Ironically, the first bullet point under the “Principles” section of the College Football Playoff website, is “Strength of Schedule,” followed by “head-to-head competition.” I guess they were at least direct in chronological order showing what was truly the highest valued variable? It’s reached a point where it matters who you play, not how you play.
So what if the playoff was only decided by SOS? *Disclaimer, I used the BCR strength of schedule, which takes the average BCR of the opponents a team has played so far- so they only get credit for the teams they’ve played. The team with the highest average opponent BCR has the toughest schedule.
| 1. Oregon (+15) 2. USC (+16) 3. Ohio State (+17) 4. Georgia (-3) 5. Alabama (-2) 6. Texas (0) 7. Tennessee (+1) 8. Kentucky (+3) 9. South Carolina (+8) 10. Ole Miss (+9) 11. LSU (+10) 12. Missouri (+10) 13. Notre Dame (-8) | 14. UCLA (-10) 15. Indiana (-6) 16. Iowa (-1) 17. BYU (-7) 18. Houston (-4) 19. Oklahoma State (+6) 20. Miami (FL) (-13) 21. Utah (-19) 22. Texas Tech (-10) 23. Arizona (0) 24. Boise State (0) 25. Wake Forest (-12) |
If you made the CFP solely from the BCR SOS rankings, 4 of the actual top 12 would be in the field. This probably isn’t the best method, for many reasons.
Wins
As the sport keeps moving to an NFL style playoff, why not look at it through the lens of the NFL playoff race- wins above all else.
| 1. Utah (+1) 2. UCLA (+2) 3. Georgia (-2) 4. Notre Dame (+1) 5. Miami (FL) (+2) 6. Indiana (+3) 7. Texas Tech (+5) 8. Wake Forest (+5) 9. Boise State (+15) 10. Alabama (-7) 11. Texas (-5) 12. Tennessee (-4) 13. BYU (-3) | 14. Kentucky (-3) 15. Houston (-1) 16. Iowa (-1) 17. USC (+1) 18. Arizona (+5) 19. Oregon (-3) 20. South Carolina (-3) 21. Ole Miss (-2) 22. Ohio State (-2) 23. LSU (-2) 24. Missouri (-2) 25. Oklahoma State (0) |
As a diehard college football fan, I hate even writing this, but there’s an important piece to this argument in that you have to have a qualifying standard. That standard is usually the win column. Under this format, 9 of the current playoff slated teams are included. Again, not my favorite method given that I think college football goes way beyond the wins and losses.
Barry’s Contender Rating
Here’s me pumping my own tires. In both 2024 and 2025, the BCR correctly projected 8 teams to make the CFP, all of them were in the top 11 of the BCR in week 11. If you were in the top 4, you all made it and the current top 4 is: Georgia, Notre Dame, Miami (FL), and Indiana.
I’ve read the tweets and the message boards explaining the desire for the return of the BCS system. Admittedly, I’ve written several emails to athletic directors across the country and even current committee members urging them to incorporate more statistics. Obviously, I want it to be my own metric(s) but any will do. No more of the pod comparison methods or resume inflated rankings, rub some stats in it and let the data talk. There’s a reason we let a computer decide championships for 15 years.
My last note, the need for a system like the BCR is crucial to preserving the integrity of the CFP as we move to 24 teams. While its paraded as “accessible” and inclusive for more “worthy” teams, it just gives more room to push agendas and biases. You should be happy you made it, who cares about seeding?
BCR Lines for Current CFP
Here are the projected lines via the BCR model, if the current CFP field were played today.
1. Georgia- BYE
2. Utah- BYE
3. Alabama- BYE
4. UCLA- BYE
12 Boise State at 5 Notre Dame (-27.5)
9 Indiana (-1) at 8 Tennessee
11 Kentucky at 6 Texas (-13)
10 BYU at 7 Miami (FL) (-9.5)
2nd Round Lines
5 Notre Dame (-4.5) vs 4 UCLA
9 Indiana vs 1 Georgia (-3.5)
6 Texas vs 3 Alabama (-2)
7 Miami (FL) vs 2 Utah (-1)
