A week ago, I headed into the weekend slate thinking “we know what most of these teams are at this point in the season.” Turns out, I hardly know anything. 5 of the top 10 lost, 2 of them to unranked opponents at home, and 2 saved on the last play of the game. Going into this weekend I look at it as “the number of teams in the tier below the contenders, is much larger than we all thought.”
Regardless of all the losses, or big wins for some, I found myself not changing how I felt about a lot of these teams. Georgia is still the best team in the nation in my opinion, but Auburn’s also bad. How true is that? They’re a few plays away from upsetting Tennessee. They’ve been one of the only teams that’s been able to score with the Florida offense all season. The same can be said about BYU, is there a reason almost anyone still believes Notre Dame is better? Miami’s had two close games, one was a good team, and one was Florida State. Was that a fluke?
This felt like the perfect time to start looking at the “blind resume.” Let’s look at what the BCR sees on these teams, from the perspective of being just a data point- no logo, no star players, or coaches- just the product on the field. Let’s test our bias and go beyond the brand
Below is a series of groups comparing 3 random teams from the BCR top 40. There’s no correlation between the teams they’re grouped with- its solely to randomize the sample of teams to eliminate potential bias. Some have CFP hopes, some are virtual locks to the final 12 teams, and others are quietly under the radar. The goal is to observe the statistical categories through the lens of the BCR and test how much is preconceived bias.



The goal isn’t to guess who these teams are, but rather compare.
- Team A: the 5th best offense on the 74th rushing attack?
- Team F: the 79th ranked defense for a top 20 team?
- Team G: The nation’s 3rd best offense lead by the BCR’s 37th highest rated QB?
Who’s the best team in this group? How would you rank them 1-3, and what’s the biggest “red flag” weakness of one of these teams?
3 teams
Ohio State, Ole Miss, LSU



- Team C: Averaging 1 fumble recovery a game is a scary attribute for a team, but they need to limit the offensive turnovers
- Team E: A truly elite offense top 15 rankings in most categories and the 4th best QB in as rated by the BCR, but the defense has trouble stopping the pass.
- Team H: A team that averages +2 in the turnover margin per game, but struggles running the ball
Which of these teams seems the safest for you to buy in on? What category makes you second guess putting weight behind them?
3 teams
Georgia, Miami (FL), Notre Dame



- Team B: A defense that struggles to turn the ball over, but is one of the safest teams at taking care of it.
- Team D: Defense leads the way for a heavy rushing attack
- Team I: The Offense and penalties may weigh them down, but the defense is dragging them to the finish line
This group of teams seems the most “unbalanced” as far as both sides of the ball, but what they do well, they are elite at. Do these resumes make you confident or warrant caution?
3 Teams
Indiana, BYU, Tennessee



- Team M: This team lives by the pass game and dies by it, allowing the worst completion percentage to opposing QBs
- Team N: what they lack in complete defense, they turn the ball over with the best of them.
- Team K: Turns the ball over nearly 2 times a game but offense sparks all the fireworks
By total accident, these three teams have in common with offense leading the way and bad pass defenses. All 3 have the buzz of playoff talks. Which one’s got the best chances at the CFP?
3 Teams
Wake Forest, Kentucky, Alabama



- Team L: One of the most underrated QBs in the nation leads a solid offense
- Team O: top 10 in takeaways covers up a bottom 5 pass defense and a near negative turnover margin
- Team J: You can write paragraphs about a defense that won’t give a better idea than just seeing they are first in yards allowed per play
The stats say this group is a few long shots for the CFP, but you’ll be surprised at the names here. Do any of these teams have a chance?
3 Teams
Northwestern, Texas Tech, Texas
Very little rivals college football for me, so I could’ve highlighted 40-50 teams. Instead, I picked a mixture of teams that were in playoff talks, high in the AP poll, or teams to test my own biases. The next group of teams was going to be UCLA, Utah, and Houston. The latter two’s matchup this weekend will make a decisive difference in each one’s BCR next week, so I felt best to exclude them. UCLA was left out because of their exclusion. Hopefully the perception of some teams was changed, even a little- good or bad. Did you lean too much on the logo?
