Who can you “trust” in college football? In a season like this one, it’s difficult to say you trust anyone. But then again what does trusting a team mean? Does it mean winning the games you should? If so, all but 2 teams have done that. Does it mean carrying out the drumming on lesser opponents? Or does it mean when the going gets tough, you can trust that they won’t roll over and they’ll answer the bell?
Per usual on this site, I like taking a concept you hear on the talk shows and discourse on the committee rankings, and do my best to quantify them. It’s completely through my own definition, but this week’s focus on quantifying “trust,” within a team from the fans perspective. In my definition, and because its the easiest to quantify, trusting a team means “trusting them not to beat/hurt themselves.” I felt this was a way to answer a root question, which would trickle down to those bigger ones: who can you trust to beat the teams they should, or carry out dominance, or lead that 4th quarter comeback.
Here’s how I did it.
I took the weighted average of 6 main variables:
- Turnovers per game– turnovers are the #1 way to kill your team
- Penalties per game– This variable is seen more as a “nerve metric”= how often do penalties effect your team, not measuring the severity of penalty
- Penalty yards per game– different from previous variable, this is aimed to measure effect on field position
- Negative Play Rate (Offense) – How often does the team take a negative play?
- Redzone Scoring Rank– this variable represents more of the “clutch” aspect= when a team is in position for points, do they leave any on the board?
- BCR Strength of Schedule– very little weight in this variable, but is to reward teams that excel vs the tougher opponents
The scale for the outputted value was between -1 and +1, with +1 meaning you’re a “trustworthy” team. Validating this calculation is not the most direct. I decided the simplest way was to look at the “trust index” in comparison to average wins. The average wins for the group of teams with a positive rating was 5.97 wins vs just 4.75 for the teams with negative ratings (a whole 1.2 wins better).
Breaking down further, the top 20 teams in the index, the average wins was 6.45. That was half a win, on average, better than the next highest range of teams.
Now, there’s a few different ways to look at these results
Filtering For the CFP Teams
This is how you decide who’s in position for a title run vs just playing the role of a participant. I am writing this before the new rankings come out Tuesday, but this past weekend’s results won’t have much effect on the top 15 in totality- most of the same teams will still be in the top 15.
This is where each of the top 15 in CFP rankings fit on the “trust index.” (Removed: Kentucky and Houston)
| Georgia- 9th Utah- 64th Alabama- 77th UCLA- 113th Notre Dame- 1st Texas- 111th Miami (FL)- 13th Tennessee- 65th | Tennessee- 65th Indiana- 3rd BYU-47th Texas Tech- 90th Wake Forest- 32nd Iowa- 15th Oregon- 31st Boise State- 4th |
As these teams get closer to the playoff field, the stakes get higher and I’ll always be weary of teams who hurt themselves.
Luck
You can also look at these standings with an idea of who’s the most lucky/unlucky? Think of the teams that are super trustworthy: don’t turn the ball over, don’t take an overwhelming amount of negative plays, and don’t leave points on the board. What if a “trustworthy” team has 7 wins while most of its index peers has 8 or 9? Maybe one thing didn’t bounce their way. Or maybe a team has 8 wins but isn’t considered trustworthy by this index. What cards fell in their favor? Was it a 3 turnover game by their defense or a missed chip shot to lose the game?
3 big names came up when trying to validate this section: Nebraska, LSU, and Texas A&M. They’re good teams that every way to hurt themselves. LSU outgunned Alabama significantly, but lost in blowout fashion. Nebraska has outgained every opponent and lead in the 4th quarter of 9/10 games. Or the tweet 2 weeks ago: “Texas A&M is the first football team in college football history to have 450+ total yards of offense, 0 turnovers, and score 0 touchdowns in the same game.” I’m not saying the sloppy play is solely to blame for these 3 teams either.
Nebraska ranks 46th, Texas A&M 71st, and LSU 99th in the Trust Index
Severities
Another perspective I found myself looking at with this index was measuring how good or bad it truly is for teams. The lowest rated team in the BCR top 15 is UCLA at 113th, followed by Texas at 111th. How telling is it that a top 5 team, 10-0, outscoring opponents by 2+ touchdowns ranks 113th? They cough up the ball over once a game (1.5/G season avg.), bottom 25 in redone scoring, and bottom 10 in penalty yards per game. I can’t help but think how much better UCLA could be if they were just able to clean up something like penalties. And that’s a crazy thought because they’re 10-0 and ranked number #4. This isn’t me saying they shouldn’t be, but it’s almost kind of impressive to be undefeated with some of their faults.
Vice versa. what does it say about a team that does all the things right, doesn’t turn the ball over, finishes drives, doesn’t rack up penalties, but can’t stack wins? Doing the little stuff right and still not winning is a frustrating place. I’m looking at Army and Fresno State, each at 5 wins, but top 10 in the trust index. It’s likely more than bad luck considering the 5-10 teams around them are closer to 7 wins than 5.
Full Index Rank
| 1. Notre Dame- 0.90 2. Army- 0.87 3. Indiana- 0.67 4. Boise State- 0.66 5. Fresno State- 0.66 6. Tulsa- 0.65 7. Illinois- 0.64 8. Colorado St- 0.64 9. Georgia- 0.62 10. W Michigan- 0.60 11. South Florida- 0.60 12. Penn State- 0.59 13. Miami (FL)- 0.57 14. Iowa State- 0.54 15. Iowa- 0.52 16. Kansas St- 0.51 17. Northwestern- 0.46 18. Oregon State- 0.45 19. Duke- 0.43 20. Minnesota- 0.41 21. Air Force- 0.41 22. MTSU- 0.40 23. N Dakota St- 0.40 24. San Jose St- 0.39 25. Arizona St- 0.39 26. Kentucky- 0.39 27. Louisiana- 0.38 28. Houston- 0.38 29. Stanford- 0.37 30. S Alabama- 0.36 31. Oregon- 0.34 32. Wake Forest- 0.33 33. West Virginia- 0.32 34. E Michigan- 0.32 35. Missouri- 0.30 36. Memphis- 0.30 37. Purdue- 0.28 38. Virginia- 0.28 39. NC State- 0.28 40. North Carolina- 0.26 41. Temple- 0.26 42. FAU- 0.26 43. Ohio- 0.25 44. Oklahoma St- 0.25 45. Delaware- 0.24 46. Nebraska- 0.24 47. BYU- 0.24 48. C Michigan- 0.21 49. Liberty- 0.20 | 50. UCF- 0.19 51. Navy- 0.18 52. Wisconsin- 0.18 53. New Mexico- 0.17 54. San Diego State- 0.17 55. Buffalo- 0.14 56. Cincinnati- 0.14 57. Arizona- 0.14 58. Umass- 0.13 59. North Texas- 0.13 60. James Madison- 0.13 61. Miami (OH)- 0.12 62. W Kentucky- 0.12 63. USC- 0.11 64. Utah- 0.11 65. Tennessee- 0.11 66. Toledo- 0.11 67. Georgia Southern- 0.11 68. Louisville- 0.10 69. Maryland- 0.09 70. Arkansas State- 0.08 71. Texas A&M- 0.07 72. UTSA- 0.06 73. Washington- 0.06 74. Ohio State- 0.06 75. Michigan State- 0.04 76. Ball State- 0.03 77. Alabama- 0.02 78. Bowling Green- -0.01 79. Arkansas- -0.02 80. App State- -0.02 81. Kennesaw st- -0.04 82. Texas State- -0.05 83. Rice- -0.05 84. Georgia State- -0.06 85. Jacksonville st- -0.06 86. Kansas- -0.07 87. ULM- -0.07 88. Wyoming- -0.08 89. Missouri State- -0.09 90. Texas Tech- -0.10 91. SMU- -0.10 92. Washington St- -0.10 93. Tulane- -0.10 94. Rutgers- -0.10 95. Uconn- -0.11 | 96. Ole Miss- -0.11 97. Florida State- -0.13 98. Pitt- -0.14 99. LSU- -0.14 100. UAB- -0.14 101. Hawaii- -0.14 102. LA Tech- -0.16 103. Nevada- -0.16 104. Virginia Tech- -0.19 105. Baylor- -0.19 106. Florida- -0.19 107. California- -0.20 108. Syracuse- -0.21 109. Clemson- -0.22 110. Charlotte- -0.26 111. Texas- -0.28 112. Utah State- -0.29 113. UCLA- -0.29 114. East Carolina- -0.31 115. Auburn- -0.31 116. FIU- -0.32 117. UNLV- -0.32 118. Sam Houston- -0.34 119. TCU- -0.34 120. Georgia Tech- -0.34 121. South Carolina- -0.35 122. Marshall- -0.36 123. Troy- -0.40 124. New Mexico St- -0.42 125. Vanderbilt- -0.42 126. Oklahoma- -0.43 127. UTEP- -0.44 128. Southern Miss- -0.44 129. Michigan- -0.47 130. Sac. St- -0.47 131. NIU- -0.48 132. Akron- -0.49 133. Coastal Carolina- -0.51 134. Kent State- -0.58 135. Colorado- -0.59 136. Boston College- -0.59 137. Mississippi st- -0.60 138. Old Dominion- -0.64 |
