BCR’s CFB Preseason Rankings 2.0


My 1.0 Rankings were a little simplistic so in this 2.0 version I implemented two more significant changes: increased the QB value and added team transfer rankings.

In my 2025 preseason rankings, I felt that I may have undervalued the QB tiers in evaluations. In the 2.0 iteration, I made the gaps between each tier a little larger to show just how important an elite QB is. My driving thought was “What was the difference in play between top BCR QBs last season, like Darian Mensah, Fernando Mendoza, Julian Sayin etc., and the 20th ranked QB in the BCR, Sawyer Robertson?” A lot.

In similar aspect to 1.0, I averaged the same 3 metrics below, but lessened the impact of metric 1. Previously, metric 1 was inflating the top end teams from the final BCR in 2025-26, lessening the weight within the average reduces the inflation.

Metric 1: 2025-26 Final overall BCR * % Overall returning production

Metric 2: (2025-26 Final overall BCR * % Overall returning production) + Returning QB’s BCR value

Metric 3: (OFF BCR * % OFF. returning production) + (DEF BCR * % DEF Returning production)

Top 75 Teams

1. Oregon

2. Notre Dame

3. Ohio State

4. Indiana

5. Georgia

6. Ole Miss

7. Texas Tech

8. Miami (FL)

9. BYU

10. USC

11. Washington

12. Texas A&M

13. Texas

14. Arizona

15. Utah

16. Virginia

17. Alabama

18. Houston

19. SMU

20. Oklahoma

21. Penn State

22. Michigan

23. Nebraska

24. Vanderbilt

25. Louisville

26. Florida State

27. Tennessee

28. Missouri

29. NC State

30. LSU

31. Auburn

32. Georgia Tech

33. Clemson

34. Iowa

35. Illinois

36. TCU

37. Pitt

38. Iowa State

39. Old Dominion

40. South Florida

41. East Carolina

42. UTSA

43. North Texas

44. Wake Forest

45. James Madison

46. Cincinnati

47. Duke

48. South Carolina

49. Toledo

50. California

51. Kansas State

52. Texas State

53. Northwestern

54. Memphis

55. Baylor

56. Fresno State

57. Minnesota

58. Boise State

59. Mississippi State

60. W Michigan

61. San Diego St

62. Arizona State

63. Kansas

64. Uconn

65. Rutgers

66. Kentucky

67. UCF

68. Arkansas

69. Ohio

70. Tulane

71. Florida

72. LA Tech

73. Navy

74. UNLV

75. W Kentucky


Risers & Fallers from 1.0 – 2.0

*Number in ( ) represents rank moving up or down

Risers

1. California (+17)

2. Oklahoma State (+17)

3. Maryland (+13)

4. South Carolina (+11)

5. UCLA (+11)

6. Minnesota (+10)

7. Arizona State (+10)

8. Kentucky (+10)

9. Colorado (+8)

10. Florida (+7)

11. Virginia Tech (+7)

12. NC State (+6)

13. Baylor (+6)

14. NDSU (+6)

15. LSU (+4)

16. Wisconsin (+4)

17. North Carolina (+4)

18. Purdue (+4)

19. Michigan (+3)

20. Auburn (+3)

Fallers

1. Navy (-6)

2. Ohio (-6)

3. Tulane (-6)

4. W Michigan (-6)

5. San Diego State (-5)

6. Boise State (-5)

7. TCU (-5)

8. Buffalo (-4)

9. J-Ville St (-4)

10. Miami (OH) (-4)

11. Southern Miss (-4)

12. Utah State (-4)

13. Uconn (-4)

14. Fresno State (-4)

15. Texas State (-4)

16. UTSA (-4)

17. Iowa (-4)

18. Nebraska (-4)

19. Ball state (-3)

20. Colorado St (-3)

Conference Rankings

*overall ranking in parenthesis

ACC

1. Miami (FL) (8)

2. Virginia (16)

3. SMU (19)

4. Louisville (25)

5. Florida State (26)

6. NC State (29)

7. Georgia Tech (32)

8. Clemson (33)

9. Pitt (37)

10. Wake Forest (44)

11. Duke (47)

12. California (50)

13. North Carolina (86)

14. Boston College (105)

15. Stanford (114)

16. Virginia Tech (125)

17. Syracuse (135)

Big Ten

1. Oregon (1)

2. Ohio State (3)

3. Indiana (4)

4. USC (10)

5. Washington (11)

6. Penn State (21)

7. Michigan (22)

8. Nebraska (23)

9. Iowa (34)

10. Illinois (35)

11. Northwestern (53)

12. Minnesota (57)

13. Rutgers (65)

14. Maryland (81)

15. Wisconsin (89)

16. Michigan State (94)

17. UCLA (97)

18. Purdue (131)

Big 12

1. Texas Tech (7)

2. BYU (9)

3. Arizona (14)

5. Utah (15)

4. Houston (18)

6. TCU (36)

7. Iowa State (38)

8. Cincinnati (46)

9. Kansas State (51)

10. Baylor (55)

11. Arizona State (62)

12. Kansas (63)

13. UCF (67)

14. Colorado (96)

15. Oklahoma State (115)

16. West Virginia (118)

SEC

1. Georgia (5)

2. Ole Miss (6)

3. Texas A&M (12)

4. Texas (13)

5. Alabama (17)

6. Oklahoma (20)

7. Vanderbilt (24)

8. Tennessee (27)

9. Missouri (28)

10. LSU (30)

11. Auburn (31)

12. South Carolina (48)

13. Mississippi State (59)

14. Kentucky (66)

15. Arkansas (68)

16. Florida (71)


Questioning Teams in 2.0 Rankings

The offseason always inflates a few teams before week 1. In 2025, Illinois, Florida, South Carolina, and Kansas State come to mind. At this point in the offseason, here’s who I am circling as teams with more questions than answers.

LSU

The Tigers are wearing a flashing a crown with three massive jewels. The jewels said, “New Head Coach,” “Transfer QB,” and “#1 Portal Class.” That’s right, the Bayou Bengals are donning their hardware for winning the offseason. The issue is that games aren’t won in June and July. I have a lot of skepticism for LSU. Returning production is favorable, but my concern comes from two aspects: the QB position and “talent effectiveness.”

When Lane Kiffin left Oxford he was essentially saying “I don’t think I can win a championship here, as much as Baton Rouge,” or why else would he leave? That team was minutes from playing in the national championship. Trinidad Chambliss and Kewan Lacy were All SEC caliber players and LSU won’t have a single offensive player better than one of them. I’m not convinced Leavitt wasn’t a Robin to Skattebo’s Batman.

As far as “talent effectiveness,” for lack of a better phrase, is basically how well will all the talent on the roster actually perform? One thing that’s massively overlooked in NIL is the impact of coaching in terms of production. Is it really a coaches fault or are these talented players underperforming in relation to portal hype? 2026 is reported to have at least 6 programs spending over $40M. I’m going to guess 2025’s figures weren’t much different. Some of the teams spending over $30M won’t sniff the playoffs. Could LSU be one of them in 2026?

Michigan

Outside of a home run hire of Kyle Whittingham, the Wolverines are a question mark for 2026. I believe Michigan’s ceiling lies in allowing Bryce Underwood to dominate in the run game. His impact was night and day difference in games against Oklahoma vs Nebraska last season. In Michigan’s 4 losses, Underwood recorded his 2nd, 3rd, and 4th worst rushing performances.

I haven’t done a total deep dive into Michigan football’s projected starters, but one thing is for certain: even with 72% returning offensive production, the skill positions around Underwood warrant caution. Justice Haynes’ departure thins RB depth, and two of the top three pass catchers won’t be returning- good for 35% of Underwood’s total pass yards in 2025.

Defensively, Michigan made a terrific hire in former BYU’s DC Jay Hill, who lead the Cougars to achieving back-to-back top 25 defenses. More specifically, top 20 rankings in takeaways the last 2 seasons. The secondary is covering up losses with some solid additions from Utah’s 2025 squad. Whittingham usually coaches a tough team with emphasis on defense. Pair that with the DC hire and I honestly expect a higher level defense in Ann Arbor.

Utah

Losing a cornerstone of a program like Kyle Whittingham is enough for me to question a lot about the Utes. Anyone could win the Big 12, Utah was there last year and because of the conference being “up for grabs,” I’m not completely ruling them out from competing. Devon Dampier is a big play maker, one of college football’s best.

Morgan Scalley commanded one of the most consistent defensive programs the last decade at Utah and took over as head coach. He promoted LB coach Colton Swan to defensive coordinator. Defensive intensity, scheme, and coaching should remain, but the transfer portal alone gashed Utah. 4- four star & 8 three star defensive players will be wearing different jerseys this fall.

Offensively, the top two pass catchers won’t return, but the backfield of Dampier and Wayshawn Parker remain. Both rushed for nearly 1k yards last season. Former Utah State OC, Kevin McGiven, takes over. His Aggies team averaged over 30ppg on a 6 win season (offense wasn’t the problem). I actually like Utah at this point in the offseason, but I can’t accurately gauge the impact of losing a guy like Whittingham.

Clemson

As long as Dabo Swinney is at Clemson, I will start every offseason thinking “is this the year Clemson reverts back to 2015-2020 dominance?” That in itself is why I listed the Tigers here, I just don’t know what to expect after last season. Week 1 had us believing both Clemson and LSU were those lofty expectation, elite-level teams. Neither panned out at all.

There was so much going for Clemson then, Cade Klubnik as a year 3 starter, Garrett Riley at OC in his 4th season (3rd with Klubnik), coming off an improbable CFP run. Heading into 2026, no familiarity remains in that aspect: Klubnik and Riley gone and the OC spot went to a guy who hasn’t served as coordinator, or assistant level, position in 6 years. His last season doing so, his offense ranked 89th in points per game.

Full disclaimer, I’m not the most well informed on Clemson Football as I write this in May, but from a bird’s eye view: Does Vizzina make a large enough leap past last year’s QB shortcomings? Do they finally find a consistent run game that won’t fizzle out in games 11-13? Can they finally bring back the dominant defensive front that lead Clemson to 8 straight (2014-2022) seasons of 42+ sacks? They’ve failed to eclipse 35 each of the last three seasons. Too much is in question for me to believe Clemson is a preseason top 25 team.

Penn State

I’ll be the first to say that Penn State firing James Franklin was a mistake. That’s not to say Matt Campbell won’t deliver, but I’m skeptical from the jump that Campbell exceeds Franklin’s accomplishments.

As far as 2026-27 goes, a lot of talent followed Campbell from Ames. The returning production in totality is a perfect 50% from last year’s Penn State team that was loaded with talent, and just underperformed. My main issue comes down to how this team is being evaluated in the transfer portal. Currently ranked as a top 10 class is way too high. We watched a lot of these Iowa State transfers, play last season in the Big 12 for team that finished 8-4. Improvement is expected/possible, but how much of the 4 star ratings are because of the destination school vs actual talent?

I do like the hire of D’Anton Lynn who drastically turned around a USC defense that was horrid for years. On the other hand Andy Kotelnicki is truly one of the best OC’s in college football and his departure will be a step back in my opinion.

Posted:

Updated:

Member of The FWAA

*If viewing on mobile device, click icon near URL along bottom of screen. Hit the smaller “A” icon until text fits screen