I’m not ready to bury a team or crown any “championship” favorites quite yet. Do I think there are clear cut contenders and clear cut “dreary days ahead” teams already this season? Absolutely. Feast week gave us some insight to that, let’s start with the bad first.
The Bad

The Bearcats beat Dayton, fell short in hosting a top 10 Louisville team, but got embarrassed on home court losing to Eastern Michigan- a team that Louisville beat by 40 just days before. It all kind of made sense when I saw Wes Miller was still the coach. It slipped my mind that he never got fired, because I thought surely he had to be gone after last season’s disappointment. Cincinnati is tough watch if you’re a fan of offense as they currently are one of the worst shooting teams in division 1- just like last season. This personally is just a sloppy team at the moment with turnovers and struggling efficiency, and it won’t get any easier in conference play. They played close with Louisville at home so that’s worth something. With the whole season ahead a turnaround could happen, but I personally will not be holding out for it to happen in Cincy.

I had high hopes for this Kansas State team coming into the season due to their transfer portal class, but I am a little uncertain about the Wildcats less than 10 games in. I’ve only seen 2 of their games, both their losses, but the losses weren’t the issue, its’ how they lost. They have one of the best pure scorers in college basketball in PJ Haggerty, but as a full team they need to fix their turnover issue. Assembly Hall is a historically difficult place to leave with a win and they clawed their way back several times in that matchup just to toss a bad pass or mishandle the ball. They are a great team offensively, but they don’t defend much at all. If you turn the ball over but at least defend, I can maybe look the other way, but doing both poorly is something I can’t buy into.
Teams who haven’t played a game away from home
The BCR values wins on the road, but I value them in the eye test even more. This comes from my dedicated years as a Hoosier fan where the splits between home and away were even worse than expected. I’d even go so far to say that if you haven’t played at least 2 games away from home court, I can’t trust that I know the kind of team you are. There’s a ton of teams who haven’t done this yet, and I think it only hurts them to later prolong it. My best example is 2024 Missouri. I think they played their first 16 games on home court and lost the first round of the tournament. You have to win 6 games away from home to win a national championship, so why schedule so many home games? To me, go on the road early and learn form your mistakes, challenge your team, and see if you can compete with anyone without the fanbase giving you extra support.
The Good

Rock Chalk Jayhawk. KU has been the single most impressive team to me so far this season. Sure they lost to two of the three best teams in the ACC away from home, but what they did over Feast Week was nothing short of spectacular. They finished the Players’ Era tournament 3-0 with wins over a very scrappy Syracuse team, Notre Dame, and a top 15 Tennessee team straight off a top 5 win the night before. Oh and they did it all without their best player in Darryn Peterson. Flory Bidunga’s improvement this season has me really buying into Kansas. But the rest of this team is set up beautifully for if/when Peterson comes back, with White and Council as Co-Stars, Bidunga down low and Tiller’s current playing level above his class status. This is where the eye test is important, as Kansas doesn’t excel at anything analytically this season, but the writing is on the wall to me that this team has a top 5 coach, a top 5 player when healthy, and a top 5 home atmosphere that’s going to help them win a lot of important games.

Sigh… I hate Purdue and will til I die. But this team is [painfully] objectively a top 3 team in the country. They likely have the player of the year in Smith too. Through this short start of the season they’ve passed every test, including demolishing Texas Tech in the Bahamas. They’re getting a ton out of their supporting cast, which is what held them back last season in my opinion. I was skeptical about the big man focus in Cluff taking production away from Trey Kaufman-Renn, but who am I compared to Matt Painter? The man knows how to coach so I don’t know why I ever questioned something like that. Loyer has caught fire at times, Smith has been lethal from 3 when the team needs it. Do they have one of the best wins of the season so far by beating Alabama in Tuscaloosa? Definitely. The thing that is really the most admirable about this team is the ball movement. Smith gets most of the credit because he’s the All-American Point Guard, but the whole team is unselfish and well coached. My God this was one of the hardest things I’ve ever written, ever- Hoosiers by a Million.

Seton Hall was the worst team in the Big East last season and looks much improved this season. They impressed me a lot by beating a team I also think is pretty good in NC State. They played with a lot of intensity vs the Wolfpack and even threw some full court pressure early in the 2nd half. That kind of speaks to the identity of this team, because they’re not the most high flying offense, but man they defend pretty well. Its good to see Shaheen Holloway get amped up on the sidelines again and I really like their leading scorer Staton-McCray who hit some big shots late in the loss to USC. On that note, Seton Hall should be undefeated at 8-0 if it hadn’t been for some questionable officiating. There was a stretch in the last 20 minutes where USC had shot like 15 FTs to Seton Hall’s 0 in the 2nd half. I liked what I saw from the Pirates in Maui.
